To Thread - Forum Home

The Mudcat Café TM
https://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=173632
4 messages

Guidance? abc explorer. 5tuplets

29 Oct 24 - 11:38 AM (#4210608)
Subject: abc explorer. 5tuplets
From: Mo the caller

I'm trying to learn the trills in Bach's Christmas Oratorio. there's a fast bit on the words "cease to be fearful" and I've put it into abc as
X:1.3
T:p3
M:3/8
L:1/8
K:D
zE/F/ (5FGFEF|GGA|BBE|BBA|AA
w:cease -------to be fear ful for get lam en ta tion

But the 5 seem to take longer that a quaver. The online guides have helped for triplets. What should I have put?


29 Oct 24 - 08:01 PM (#4210640)
Subject: RE: Guidance? abc explorer. 5tuplets
From: Jack Campin

Try (5:2:5FGFEF.

ABC standards are confused about how to display tuplet beaming. I just tried Michael Eskin's thing (built around abcjs) and it uses single beams when they should be double but I think it plays it right. Maybe (5F/G/F/E/F/ would be better.


30 Oct 24 - 04:31 AM (#4210648)
Subject: RE: Guidance? abc explorer. 5tuplets
From: DaveRo

You can play it HERE. I suggest you slow it down by changing the tempo on the black bar to, say, 30%

I tried Jacks's suggestion by editing the ABC: it sounded the same to me.

I added a second voice and played about with it. I found 5:1:5 works - See Here

(ABC Explorer might sound different.)


30 Oct 24 - 05:57 PM (#4210684)
Subject: RE: Guidance? abc explorer. 5tuplets
From: Mo the caller

Thanks. I think (5F/G/F/E/F/ sorts it.