|
12 Apr 02 - 06:27 PM (#688802) Subject: Duelling banjoes..help! From: greg stephens The normal lineup of the band I play with is fiddle,accordion,guitar,washboard, and a bit of trombone. I have lost count of the number of times we are asked to play Duelling Banjoes. What exactly is going on here? |
|
12 Apr 02 - 06:38 PM (#688808) Subject: RE: Duelling banjoes..help! From: SharonA "What exactly is going on here?" Well, it seems that the audience is taking the name of the song less literally than the band is! "Dueling Banjos" is just the name of a song. I mean, you don't need to be standing in a forest to play "Wildwood Flower", right? You don't need to have a cardinal perched on your shoulder to play "Red Wing." You don't need to fly yourselves and your audience to the US to play "Banks of the Ohio". So why not just play the song with the instruments at hand, and have fun with it? :^) |
|
12 Apr 02 - 06:42 PM (#688814) Subject: RE: Duelling banjoes..help! From: greg stephens Well, believe me weve tried but the twiddly bit is a bit difficult to do justice to onthe instruments we have. My theory is the requesters are confused between Deliverance and Souyhern Comfort. |
|
12 Apr 02 - 06:50 PM (#688822) Subject: RE: Duelling banjoes..help! From: SharonA Greg: Yeah, I can see where it could be a problem to play it on trombone! |
|
12 Apr 02 - 06:50 PM (#688825) Subject: RE: Duelling banjoes..help! From: Jeri Dueling Banjos is basically a tarted up Yankee Doodle, if that helps at all. It's dead simple on fiddle. It might be more interesting if you had the accordian and trombone doing the leads. I'd be tempted to work up an a capella version of it, though. |
|
12 Apr 02 - 06:52 PM (#688827) Subject: RE: Duelling banjoes..help! From: Anahootz ow... I just had a mental soundtrack loop of "dueling banjos" on accordion and trombone... |
|
12 Apr 02 - 06:58 PM (#688833) Subject: RE: Duelling banjoes..help! From: Jeri I have a vague memory of a Dr Demento radio show, and "Dueling Tubas." |
|
12 Apr 02 - 07:08 PM (#688837) Subject: RE: Duelling banjoes..help! From: Gypsy Minstrels of Mayhem have a song version of dueling banjos....pretty good to check out. Any of us will play it...EXCEPT our banjo player. But i wont play Greensleeves without heavy bribery, either (hammer dulcimer) |
|
12 Apr 02 - 07:14 PM (#688841) Subject: RE: Duelling banjoes..help! From: Snuffy Mudcatter Geoff the Duck plays it solo on banjo and kazoo! |
|
12 Apr 02 - 07:44 PM (#688867) Subject: RE: Duelling banjoes..help! From: Sorcha In the movie it was a guitar and a banjo--not 2 banjos. It really should work with a guitar and a fiddle. All the melody line does is move up a 3rd each time. Add a few bad "match this" notes, and you've got it made. |
|
13 Apr 02 - 06:35 AM (#689038) Subject: RE: Duelling banjoes..help! From: Bullfrog Jones Geoff -- The Bullfrogs get this too! (The fact that you can play DB on other instruments is irrelevant -- the kind of dimwit who asks for it expects a banjo). I usually ask the requester to point out the banjo he'd like it played on. Funnily enough our drummer has recently taken up the banjo -- two musical stereotypes for the price of one! Maybe when he's good enough.... Incidentally Duelling Tubas was by Martin Mull and it's hilarious, as is his 2001 Polka. BJ |
|
13 Apr 02 - 06:56 AM (#689044) Subject: RE: Duelling banjoes..help! From: greg stephens Thanks Bullfrog, you got my point, why are they asking for the tune when they cant see a banjo.The duelling tubas is classic.And you can indeed play it on a trombone. Another interesting question, specially to you Bullfrog,is why have people persisted all my life in calling me geoff when my name is greg? This always happens to people called greg..they dont sound or look that close. |
|
13 Apr 02 - 07:05 AM (#689046) Subject: RE: Duelling banjoes..help! From: Bullfrog Jones Yes!!! My given name is Malcolm (so you'll see why Bullfrog is preferable) but if someone gets my name wrong it's ALWAYS Graham! I've been called Graham by so many different people in different places and different times that I've decided I must really LOOK like a Graham! |
|
13 Apr 02 - 08:56 AM (#689079) Subject: RE: Duelling banjoes..help! From: Jeri That's your answer then: Greg = Geoff Malcolm = Graham Fiddle = Banjo |
|
13 Apr 02 - 11:49 AM (#689133) Subject: Martin Mull: Dueling Tubas From: GUEST,Gene Picked up that old LP for 50 cents at the flea market...
laughed till i cried.... |
|
13 Apr 02 - 01:23 PM (#689209) Subject: RE: Duelling banjoes..help! From: Geoff the Duck I worked up the Duelling Banjo and Kazoo routine when I got fed-up with being asked for duelling banjoes (usually by some bloke holding a guitar, expecting me to do all the work and him bum along for half of the applause). As it happens I do NOT play bluegrass banjo, so I did the flash bits on kazoo and the accompaniment was clawhammer style on the five-string. I reckon a trombone would sound brilliant on the runs, especially with rip-snorting slurs and glissandoes. By the way, Bullfrog. Where are you based. I recall a band of that name playing pubs around Bradford when I used to live there. Was that you, or is it a coincidence of names? Quack!!! Geoff the Duelling Duck! |
|
13 Apr 02 - 01:51 PM (#689231) Subject: RE: Duelling banjoes..help! From: Coyote Breath Well once upon a time a fellow banjo player and I were asked to play duelling banjoes. Simultaneously, without any plan we both picked up our banjoes by the braces and holding them like epees we shouted "en garde" and proceeded to dance about the stage ala Eroll Flynn. Brought the house down. CB |
|
13 Apr 02 - 01:57 PM (#689233) Subject: RE: Duelling banjoes..help! From: Anahootz Sort of a threadcreep here, but has anyone heard the cover of the Black Sabbath tune "War Pigs" done by Alice Donut? If you have ever wondered what heavy metal sounds like performed on tuba and trombone, this is for you... Now back to your regularly scheduled programming. |