To Thread - Forum Home

The Mudcat Café TM
https://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=52848
15 messages

Lyr Add: wrote this for a friend (Memories Stay)

24 Oct 02 - 12:36 PM (#810267)
Subject: BS: wrote this for a friend
From: Amergin

Well...I wrote this for a friend...who's brother was killed in Bali...and well i was wondering what you all thought before i sent it to her...

Memories Stay (title not in stone as yet)
(tune: Water is Wide)

There is a candle it burns right well
Shining bright in my heart it dwells
But the wind it came strong and stout
And blew that bright burning candle out

Oh, he was staying there in Bali Town
When the bombs blew the hotel down
And the blast shook me to the bone
For now he'll never be coming home

I see him coming through the door
I hear his steps stomp across the floor
I hear his voice whisper soft and clear
As my fingers feel my hot wet tears

In the window a candle burns bright
Calling him home in the dark night
The pain it fades as the years go by
But the memories stay in my heart nearby

nt



Thanks...


24 Oct 02 - 12:46 PM (#810275)
Subject: RE: BS: wrote this for a friend
From: MMario

'gin - I would put the second verse last if it were me. Other then that all I can say is "goose bumps".


24 Oct 02 - 12:48 PM (#810280)
Subject: RE: BS: wrote this for a friend
From: Tam the bam fraeSaltcoatsScotland

I think that it is a fine song, Amergin.

Tom Hamilton


24 Oct 02 - 12:53 PM (#810285)
Subject: RE: BS: wrote this for a friend
From: artbrooks

Were it me (and I can't even write BAD poetry), I think I'd leave out the second verse entirely, or find an alternative to "When the bombs blew the hotel down". That line evokes a different, and more violent, image than the rest of it does.

Please understand that I only commented because you asked. The entire thing is excellent.


24 Oct 02 - 01:07 PM (#810292)
Subject: RE: BS: wrote this for a friend
From: GUEST,glenda 53 at work

Excellent work. I wouldn't change a thing. IMHO
g


24 Oct 02 - 01:18 PM (#810304)
Subject: RE: BS: wrote this for a friend
From: Declan

A great piece of work. A few small suggestions :

The first two lines of the second verse don't work for me either. Is there a Bali Town ? I don't know. I'd have another look at these.

Line one in verse 4 would scan better if it was "A candle burns in the window bright". Line three in that verse might be better as "The pain may fade as the years go by" - just seems that its a bit soon to say that the pain will fade.


24 Oct 02 - 01:44 PM (#810313)
Subject: RE: BS: wrote this for a friend
From: Clinton Hammond

Ya... nice... but I agree... the 2nd verse is out of place... maybe try some circumlocution... talk about it, without stating it directly...


24 Oct 02 - 04:09 PM (#810413)
Subject: RE: BS: wrote this for a friend
From: Amergin

how's this for the second verse?


my heart stopped beating when the phone rang
I heard the news as the salt tears sang
The blast it shook me to the bone
For now he'll never be coming home


24 Oct 02 - 04:15 PM (#810419)
Subject: RE: BS: wrote this for a friend
From: Amos

Amergin:

Wind is hardly ever thought of as "stout". You could call it "stark" and rhyme it with "turned that burning candle dark..." or "bold and cold, or grim and dim, or shift it around some other way.

A nice piece of work, man!


A


24 Oct 02 - 04:20 PM (#810425)
Subject: RE: BS: wrote this for a friend
From: MMario

Amos - "a stout wind" is actually a pretty common phrase


24 Oct 02 - 08:58 PM (#810620)
Subject: RE: BS: wrote this for a friend
From: Stephen L. Rich

It's wonderful! Send it!

Stephen Lee


25 Oct 02 - 03:44 PM (#811332)
Subject: RE: BS: wrote this for a friend
From: Amergin

ok here's what looks to be the final product...thanks all...

The Memories Stay
(tune: Water is Wide)

There is a candle it burns right well
Shining bright in my heart it dwells
But the wind it came strong and stout
And blew that bright burning candle out

My heart stopped beating when the phone rang
I heard the news as the salt tears sang
The blast it shook me to the bone
For now he'll never be coming home

I see him coming through the door
I hear his steps stomp across the floor
I hear his voice whisper soft and clear
As my fingers feel my hot wet tears

In the window a candle burns bright
Calling him home in the dark night
The pain may fade as the years go by
But the memories stay in my heart nearby

nt


25 Oct 02 - 03:48 PM (#811341)
Subject: RE: BS: wrote this for a friend
From: MMario

still giving me chills and goose bumps - good work!


25 Oct 02 - 03:53 PM (#811346)
Subject: RE: BS: wrote this for a friend
From: Amos

Main Entry:        1stout
Pronunciation:        'staut
Function:        adjective
Etymology:        Middle English, from Middle French estout, of Germanic origin; akin to Old High German stolz proud; perhaps akin to Old High German stelza stilt -- more at STILT
Date:        14th century
1 : strong of character: as a : BRAVE, BOLD b : FIRM, DETERMINED; also : OBSTINATE
2 : physically or materially strong: a : STURDY, VIGOROUS b : STAUNCH, ENDURING c : sturdily constructed
3 : FORCEFUL ; also : VIOLENT
4 : bulky in body
synonym see STRONG
- stout·ish /'stau-tish/ adjective
- stout·ly adverb


By God, look at that!! I stand corrected, comment withdrawn. Thanks, guys!! Long time!! :>) And here i thought I knew EVERYTHING!


A


25 Oct 02 - 04:38 PM (#811369)
Subject: RE: BS: wrote this for a friend
From: Clinton Hammond

Stout gives me the wind from time to time...

,-)