To Thread - Forum Home

The Mudcat Café TM
https://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=54084
16 messages

Alicia Keys: Fallin'

26 Nov 02 - 01:46 PM (#835512)
Subject: Alicia Keyes: Fallen
From: GUEST

Not to interrupt all the BS here, but I'm surprised we haven't seen any discussions of this young 'un. I'm currently listening to this song, which grew so much on me from my kids MTV airplay, that I went out and bought the CD. Here is a girl who has ALL the talent. Voice, instrumental chops (though I know they'll get better) and arranging and writing talent.

Anyone else "fallen" for this great new talent?


26 Nov 02 - 01:50 PM (#835513)
Subject: RE: Alicia Keyes: Fallen
From: GUEST

Oops--spelling correction (I hit send, before I previewed). Fallin' is the name of the song, and her last name is spelled Keys.

I love this girl!


26 Nov 02 - 01:51 PM (#835514)
Subject: RE: Alicia Keyes: Fallen
From: MMario

What's the song?


26 Nov 02 - 02:00 PM (#835517)
Subject: RE: Alicia Keyes: Fallen
From: GUEST

The title of the song is "Fallin" and is found on her newest CD "Songs in A Minor". The girl can wail, smolder, and growl in the best sense of the blues and R & B tradition.


26 Nov 02 - 02:06 PM (#835518)
Subject: RE: Alicia Keyes: Fallen
From: irishajo

I liked the song, but I haven't heard any of her other stuff. I thought "Fallin'" was surprisingly understated for such a popular song.


26 Nov 02 - 02:19 PM (#835522)
Subject: RE: Alicia Keyes: Fallen
From: GUEST

Well, her MTV thing may end up killing her. But if she can get beyond it (not easy at her tender young age, and the desire to be accepted by her peers), and stay focused on the music, I predict she will become one of the greats.


26 Nov 02 - 05:36 PM (#835576)
Subject: RE: Alicia Keys: Fallin'
From: GUEST

Thanks elves for correcting my errors.


27 Nov 02 - 02:02 PM (#835863)
Subject: RE: Alicia Keys: Fallin'
From: Kim C

Mister and I saw her on Saturday Night Live awhile back and both agreed that she is pretty incredible. Definitely outstanding amongst the crop of young poppers these days.

Ditto for india.arie.


27 Nov 02 - 02:45 PM (#835899)
Subject: RE: Alicia Keys: Fallin'
From: Firecat

I think she's brilliant.


27 Nov 02 - 03:53 PM (#835941)
Subject: RE: Alicia Keys: Fallin'
From: GUEST

KimC, I'm curious. Why do you label Alicia Keys' music as pop? I mean, Britney or Macy Gray she ain't! Now, india.arie I would label pop. But this one CD of Alicia Keys' that I have definitely doesn't sound like pop--R & B for sure, with some blues stuff mixed in.


27 Nov 02 - 04:29 PM (#835966)
Subject: RE: Alicia Keys: Fallin'
From: Kim C

I didn't mean that her music is pop - it isn't. I meant that she stands out from the pop artists on the radio. Here in Nashville she gets played on the pop stations right alongside Britney and Pink and the like.


27 Nov 02 - 04:31 PM (#835971)
Subject: RE: Alicia Keys: Fallin'
From: GUEST

There you go! That makes sense. Like I said, I first saw her on MTV, so you are right, she is getting cross-over airplay. And fair play to her for that too! But I put her stylistically in the R & B and blues genre. She has one set of pipes, that girl!


27 Nov 02 - 04:37 PM (#835976)
Subject: RE: Alicia Keys: Fallin'
From: beadie

I haven't heard it. Is it the same "Falling" that Lennon and McCartney wrote for the Beatles (later done as a banjo-heavy bluegrass number by ???)?


28 Nov 02 - 04:26 AM (#836306)
Subject: RE: Alicia Keys: Fallin'
From: mooman

I agree with most of what's been said. I have the CD and would consider Alicia as one of the front runners in a surprising crop of real new talent arising from the derivative quagmire that is a lot of today's "MTV culture" music. I would also put some others like Meshell Ndegeocello in this "excellent" category.

mooman


28 Nov 02 - 10:08 AM (#836485)
Subject: RE: Alicia Keys: Fallin'
From: GUEST

No beadie, it isn't the same song. The lyrics to the song aren't all that great (which is true of a lot of writing on the album). But the delivery makes you not really care! In fact, I'd say the lyrics are the one weak point Keys will have to work on. But she doesn't have too many weak points for a woman of her tender age.

mooman, I agree about Meshell Ndegeocello too. I just hope the pop industry doesn't take them away, and that they aren't destroyed by the MTV/BET culture. It must be very difficult for young musicians to try and make it these days in the R & B world. They are getting pulled in a lot of different directions that previous generations haven't had to deal with. Makes me hope someone sits down next to them every single day and says "the cable TV industry isn't the REAL music world". God knows, the music business is bad enough!


28 Nov 02 - 03:16 PM (#836684)
Subject: RE: Alicia Keys: Fallin'
From: GUEST,fat B****rd

And she did a gig at the House of Commons...