|
12 Jan 03 - 05:20 AM (#865034) Subject: Obit: Bee Gees-And then there were two From: Little Robyn They've just announced on our news that Maurice Gibb has died. Although not a folkie, he and his brothers have been making music for over 40 years! A sad loss to the music world. Robyn |
|
12 Jan 03 - 05:30 AM (#865038) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees-And then there were two From: Fiolar Sad news indeed. This is not the first tragedy for the family. His brother Andy died in 1988 just after his 30th birthday. |
|
12 Jan 03 - 06:36 AM (#865052) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees-And then there were two From: oombanjo Our parties back in the 70s and 80s would have been crap without them. He will be missed. |
|
12 Jan 03 - 06:45 AM (#865058) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees-And then there were two From: Dave the Gnome I remember the Bee Gees more for their early work. Stuff Like New York mining disaster 19(whatever) and The first of May. Very original stuff and a far cry from the commerciality of the 70's. What I have heard of Robins new solo album sound very promising as well. It is tragic that Maurice has died before his time though. It means that the Brothers Gibb are indeed sadly depleted. I hope they recover from their loss and that his family find the strength to carry on and continue with making good music in his memory. Cheers Dave the Gnome |
|
12 Jan 03 - 07:25 AM (#865066) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees-And then there were two From: catspaw49 geeziz......this one is unbelievable. Maurice was so enthusiastic and seemed to just love life.... Obit says he died of cardiac arrest just prior to ondergoing emergency surgery for an intestinal blockage....... Today sucks... Spaw |
|
12 Jan 03 - 07:49 AM (#865076) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees-And then there were two From: GUEST,john c The Bee Gees were the first group I ever saw live, around `66 in Edinburgh and they were magic. Apart from inspiring me to learn the guitar, their music has remained with me ever since. To Love Somebody is still one my all-time faves. Very, very sad news. |
|
12 Jan 03 - 08:30 AM (#865095) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees-And then there were two From: John MacKenzie Any mention of the Bee Gees calls to mind my favourite Kenny Everett sketch, where he played them all, complete with mega teeth. God rest his soul. At least he'll never have to walk out of another Clive Anderson show. Giok |
|
12 Jan 03 - 10:45 AM (#865152) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees-And then there were two From: katlaughing What Spaw said, big time. |
|
12 Jan 03 - 12:11 PM (#865253) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees-And then there were two From: fat B****rd I especially liked "To Love Somebody" great version by Nina Simone, too. RIP Maurice. |
|
12 Jan 03 - 12:35 PM (#865276) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees-And then there were two From: GUEST,joe clone Moved over from a duplicate thread: Subject: Obit: maurice gibb From: Steve Benbows protege - PM Date: 12 Jan 03 - 12:20 PM Just come over the news on the computer Maurice Gibb has sadly gone to the musicians party in the sky. Not my favourite band but still respected him for his musicianship.My thoughts go out to his family. Subject: RE: Obit: maurice gibb From: khandu - PM Date: 12 Jan 03 - 12:22 PM Any details? Subject: RE: Obit: maurice gibb From: khandu - PM Date: 12 Jan 03 - 12:29 PM Before they hopped on the Disco Train and rode it to Hell, I enjoyed the BeeGees very much. "Got to get a message to you", "Massachusetts" were good songs. Sorry to hear of his departure. k |
|
12 Jan 03 - 03:09 PM (#865327) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: Firecat Very sad news. One of the very first singles I bought was the BeeGees "Alone", and one of my favourite songs is "How Deep Is Your Love". Rest In Peace Maurice. You were a true musical genius. |
|
12 Jan 03 - 03:17 PM (#865330) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: Genie Fox news reported this morning that the Bee Gees were planning to put out a new album in the near future. They were not content to be thought of only as "disco" artists. They not only recorded but wrote a number of memorable songs. Very sad news. |
|
12 Jan 03 - 03:56 PM (#865360) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: Benjamin I've always loved everything I've heard them do, no matter when or how they did it. One of my favortes also is If I Can't Have You sung by Yvonne Elliman (written by the BeeGees). I also agree with what Spaw said! Benjamin |
|
12 Jan 03 - 04:04 PM (#865361) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: GUEST Genie says: The Bee Gees ... were not content to be thought of only as "disco" artists Only a fool would consider them in that way. I liked the 60s stuff a bit, but I thought that they were at their best as writers and producers. The late 70s/80s era of "Woman in Love" "Heartbreaker" etc. reveals, if nothing else, excellent songsmiths. Rest well, Maurice. |
|
12 Jan 03 - 07:57 PM (#865507) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: GUEST Thanks Guest. To be honest, although I recognised thier success and am sorry to read of Maurice's demise, the "Saturday Night Fever" stuff left me cold. I didn't enjoy the music or the high pitched singing. "Woman In Love" was a beautiful song... It seems that one was Robin/Barry Gibb. Any Maurice Gibb songs? |
|
12 Jan 03 - 09:27 PM (#865557) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: DancingMom My Mom loved them. |
|
12 Jan 03 - 09:59 PM (#865576) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: Little Robyn Someone on the local radio said Maurice was bass - presumably in the harmony section rather than instrumentally. Which means he probably didn't do many solos or leads. I'm not really a fan of their music but I appreciate their harmonies and they did a lot for the early pop scene in Australia (which helped NZ too). Also, I admire their 'local louts make good' story. Robin and Maurice must have been about 8 years old when they started performing in public. According to their biography, they were heading for borstal but found fame instead. Good on ya boys. Robyn |
|
12 Jan 03 - 10:05 PM (#865582) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: mousethief I really loved their pre-disco stuff. And post-disco stuff. Loads o'talent. RIP, Maurice. May your memory be eternal. Alex |
|
12 Jan 03 - 10:10 PM (#865589) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: Lonesome EJ Words was my favorite Beegees song...it's only words, and words are all I have to win your steal your heart away. Didn't like the disco stuff. Sorry about Maurice anyway. PS Are these guys Aussies or English? |
|
12 Jan 03 - 11:56 PM (#865656) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: Little Robyn Born in England (Liverpool?) shifted to Australia (Queensland?) in the 50s, overcame poverty to become stars in the 60s and shifted back to England about 1967/68. Now they seem to have houses all over. |
|
13 Jan 03 - 12:39 AM (#865675) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: GUEST,Tom Hamilton Sad that Maurice is dead, I liked their song words, of which I've still got. It's old and crackly, I liked their Harmonies and most of their songs as well. So sad to hear about his death. |
|
13 Jan 03 - 02:29 AM (#865704) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: Steve Benbows protege NO point saying "Staying Alive" Then? I better dissapear befor I get hounded out! |
|
13 Jan 03 - 05:02 AM (#865770) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: fat B****rd They were born on the Isle of Man and lived in Manchester before emigrating to Australia. |
|
13 Jan 03 - 06:37 AM (#865800) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: Sandra in Sydney The Gibb brothers were 8 & 14 when they started singing at the local motor races, between the races, for no fee, folks just threw money. The twins were a wild pair, so it sounds like the bit about them heading for Borstal might be true. Today I heard an interview with the DJ who discovered them - he & the promoter of the races were responsible for their name. Both men had the initials BG, & the DJ referred to himself on air as "BG from (station name)" & taped them & sent the tape of the until then un-named trio to Sydney's top DJ & they were on their way to fame & fortune. sandra |
|
13 Jan 03 - 06:54 AM (#865803) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: Sandra in Sydney the article referred to above, URL copied http://www.abc.net.au/rn/talks/brkfast/stories/s762007.htm I tried to make a blue clicky but the test said the link didn't work sandra |
|
13 Jan 03 - 07:12 AM (#865812) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: Mr Happy never liked any of their 'castrato' stuff- but the early ones were good. the mining disaster one was great- like a folk song btw- anyone have the words for it? |
|
13 Jan 03 - 10:11 AM (#865908) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were From: SharonA Sad news indeed, and quite a loss. Apparently, the obituary that Catspaw read was incorrect. News reports are now saying that Maurice Gibb had a cardiac arrest before the emergency surgery for an intestinal blockage, but that he lived for a time after that. He had been rushed to Mount Sinai Medical Center in Miami on Thursday night (January 9th) with severe stomach pains but did not pass away until late Saturday or early Sunday morning. Late yesterday, Barry Gibb made a statement to the BBC on behalf of the family, questioning Maurice's treatment at the hospital. His words, quoted on ABCNews.com: "The fact that they had to operate on Maurice during the shock of cardiac arrest, is very questionable, and we will pursue every factor, every element, every second of the timeline of the final hours of Maurice's life. We will pursue that relentlessly. That will be our quest from now on." He also said he had been told that Maurice's intestines were twisted because of a congenital defect and that doctors had removed 80 percent of his stomach during the surgery. After the surgery until his passing, Maurice's condition had been listed as critical but stable. There's no word yet about the immediate cause of death or what caused his condition to destablilize. A second cardiac arrest? Internal bleeding? I certainly don't blame the family for wanting to be sure that it wasn't caused by some mistake on the part of hospital staff. Whatever the reason, Maurice's passing must be a terrible shock to his loved ones. |
|
13 Jan 03 - 11:15 AM (#865962) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: Dave the Gnome Try here or here for another favourite. In fact, Why not look at all the lyrics. I was astounded at just the shere output - let alone the quality! Cheers DtG |
|
13 Jan 03 - 01:13 PM (#866043) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: catspaw49 Actually Sharon, that's about the same as what I sadi I'd read initially but it now appears there is some confusion on what happened and when which is what the family is questioning. The reports in the news vary as to whether the heart attack occured before or during the surgery for the intestinal problem. The congenital problem they describe was obviously quite serious as he collapsed at home on Wednesday. These conditions are not always susceptible to treatment without surgery. I'm not standing up for the Docs at this point, but I'd say since they removed 80% of his stomach (allegedly), then the intestinal problem was life threatening itself. Not many Docs will take on a high risk surgery without some discussion and I don't know that happened, but he had licked a cocaine problem and was a recovering alchoholic and smoker as well so the heart risk was probably high going in. When it comes to multiple problems then sometimes, depending on how serious the condition is, you roll the dice. Been there, done that. The family deserves some answers on what happened and when as well as the reasoning behind the surgery......Also, someone had to sign for this surgery as well. No matter.......a tragic loss to the music and to his family that he loved deeply. Spaw |
|
13 Jan 03 - 05:40 PM (#866230) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were From: SharonA Spaw: Thanks for the clarification. I was confused by your initial post wherein you said you'd read that he died of the cardiac arrest just prior to undergoing the surgery (or did you mean that he died after the surgery as a result of the heart attack before the surgery?). I just wanted to make it clear that the reports say he lived for some time after the surgery. Indeed, a tragic loss. |
|
17 Jan 03 - 06:09 PM (#869124) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: katlaughing We watched a great documentary on them last night on the True Stories channel. Most of what it showed Maurice doing, even up to just recently, was keyboard, esp. fleshing out the tunes as they composed them together in the studio while jamming around. Thye said they always did the tune first then lyrics to match. They made it very clear that they never changed the tune to fit any words. The words had to fit or they got changed. They said after Andy died, even though he was a drug and alcohol addict, they found he had a heart problem which he'd known about for two years but had never told anyone else about it and that was basically what killed him. It was wonderful to see them working together and to hear them perform. Some of my favs include To Love Somebody and Words. Here is a really neat picture of Maurice at 15: click here. |
|
17 Jan 03 - 07:26 PM (#869165) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: GUEST,Neil Comer The Bee Gees sang a song called Eilean Vannin (= Oileán Mhanann= The Isle of Mann) on a live recording that I saw on MTV. It had folk elements and showed their underlying soul |
|
17 Jan 03 - 08:30 PM (#869192) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: JennyO We sang "Words" last night at our singing session. Everyone was looking a bit misty-eyed. Jenny |
|
17 Jan 03 - 10:59 PM (#869247) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: Mark Cohen Just to shed a bit of light on the medical issue, which is still quite confusing. I believe that the congenital condition Maurice had is something called intestinal malrotation, and is not in itself fatal, but predisposes a person to a fatal complication. Malrotation happens during embryonic life. Normally, during development, the entire intestinal tract rotates in such a way that its blood supply (called the mesentery) gets "tacked down" neatly to the back of the abdominal cavity. If this does not happen, the "free-floating" mesentery can spontaneously twist on itself, kinking the major arteries and blocking the blood supply to part of the intestine: like twisting a loop in a garden hose. This condition, called volvulus, causes sudden excruciating abdominal pain, and, if not rapidly corrected by surgery, results in the death of some of the intestine, and, commonly, the patient. In a person who is born with malrotation, volvulus can occur at any time from infancy to adulthood....or never (though most of the time it happens in infancy or childhood, and is one of the causes of intestinal obstruction in a a newborn). There's no way of predicting or preventing it, unless the malrotation is detected by X-ray studies, that may be done for some unrelated problem. There are other malformations of the intestine that can lead to volvulus as well. From the little bit I've read about this case (which is undoubtedly only partly related to the truth), it would be surprising if physician error played any part in Maurice's death. Not impossible, but it's certainly not what would leap to mind. It sounds like he had a cardiac arrest from some unknown cause (heart attack would be a likely guess), was resuscitated, then developed the volvulus, had to have emergency surgery to try to save his gut, and the stress was too much for his damaged heart. Just a guess, but at least it's an educated one. Aloha, Mark |
|
20 Jan 03 - 08:12 AM (#870432) Subject: RE: Obit: Bee Gees- Maurice - And then there were two From: GUEST,Rex on the work 'puter Back in the 70's when they were cranking out the disco stuff, we would mutter and say that they used to write good songs. I am still grateful for their early work. Maurice is gone all too soon. Rex |