|
17 Jun 03 - 02:58 PM (#967828) Subject: songs I wish I'd written From: GUEST,Tunesmith I'm a bit of a songwriter, and I think I'm getting better but now and again I hear a song and I think, " Now, that's the way it should be done!" My choice for the number one " folkie" type song that I wished I'd written, " White Squall" by Stan Rogers. Why? The lyrics, the tune , the sadness it evokes, and the drama of the tale that moves me so much - especially the way Stan delivers it. |
|
17 Jun 03 - 03:04 PM (#967832) Subject: RE: songs I wish I'd written From: Wolfgang It's about time for a new thread with this theme. An older thread (from last century) is here: Wish I'd written that song Wolfgang |
|
17 Jun 03 - 03:19 PM (#967842) Subject: RE: songs I wish I'd written From: GUEST,mg I wish I had written the town I love so well..I would change it a bit but not much...mg |
|
17 Jun 03 - 03:43 PM (#967858) Subject: RE: songs I wish I'd written From: GUEST,Tunesmith What makes a song great? Sometimes it's little touches that make a song " real", and lift it above the usual fayre. Take Steve Goodman's " Yellow Coat". The idea is an old one: for example, Willie Nelson's " Funny How Time Slips Away" and the ancient "standard "( 1930s?) What's New" tell the same story. A man ( or woman ) meets an old flame, and the listener hears one side of the conversation; now, in " Yellow Coat " the person doing the talking suddenly asks, " Did you ever get to buy that yellow coat?" That is a master's touch. It adds a terrific sense of "truth" to an already beautifully concieved song. Obviously, just around the time the couple split up the female half of the relationship had been admiring a yellow coat in a store window. This is a master songwriter at work. There are not many out there who could have written that song. |
|
17 Jun 03 - 06:27 PM (#967985) Subject: RE: songs I wish I'd written From: yrlancslad MacColls Joy of living, Jez Lowes Indian Maid and Had away gan an. Probably a dozen more if I thik about it. |
|
17 Jun 03 - 06:49 PM (#968003) Subject: RE: songs I wish I'd written From: GUEST,Fogie Which LP is white squall on? I've just crossed the Atlantic on a tall ship, and watched "White squall" on video after a force 10 gale , and I thought I'd got all of Stan's LPs. Can't stand the suspense |
|
17 Jun 03 - 08:56 PM (#968079) Subject: RE: songs I wish I'd written From: Stewie 'White Squall' is the first track on 'From Fresh Water' Fogarty's Cove FCM-007-D. --Stewie. |
|
17 Jun 03 - 09:22 PM (#968092) Subject: RE: songs I wish I'd written From: Rapparee Good Lord! How can anyone...? Mary Ellen Carter The Idiot And The Band Played Waltzing Matilda Puff the Magic Dragon This Land Is Your Land It's Not Easy Bein' Green Rainbow Connection Seasons In The Sun The Yew Tree ("...ma bonny yew tree/Tell me what did you see?") Bold Fenian Men Yankee Doodle My Son John Willie McBride Queensland Overlanders Lyndon Johnson Told The Nation There But For Fortune Sully's Bucket and about 200 more. Literally. |
|
18 Jun 03 - 07:21 AM (#968292) Subject: RE: songs I wish I'd written From: GUEST,Tunesmith What is interesting is that when people compile lists of "best song" and "worst songs" , the same songs pop up on each list. For example, lots of people hear Eric Clapton's " Wonderful Tonight" as a great romantic song, whereas lots of others think it's sugary nonsense , or condecending to women. You can't please all the people all the time. For example, I was amazed to hear somebody once say that they hated " Greensleeves". Surely, not ... |
|
18 Jun 03 - 07:43 AM (#968296) Subject: RE: songs I wish I'd written From: George Papavgeris There's lots of good stuff out there, to please any taste. Thank God for the excellent songwriters we have had the privilege to benefit from across the years/centuries. But still, |
|
18 Jun 03 - 07:46 AM (#968297) Subject: RE: songs I wish I'd written From: George Papavgeris (clicked the wrong button before) ... were I to leave now, there's nothing more I would regret: not hearing those songs that nobody has written yet.... I would gladly forego TODAY sight, touch and much more besides, to have the opportunity to hear the songs that will be written after I'm gone. |
|
18 Jun 03 - 07:58 AM (#968300) Subject: RE: songs I wish I'd written From: A Wandering Minstrel Yeah "Greensleeves" is a lot o sugary claptrap and is not a patch on Bluff Hals lesser known masterwork "Passtimes in Good Company" Fie, the Minstreles Tongue be so encheeked! :) |
|
18 Jun 03 - 10:46 AM (#968419) Subject: RE: songs I wish I'd written From: GUEST Fred Eaglesmith's "Water In The Fuel" off Lipstick, Lies, and Gasoline (great CD title too) ...although I like Kasey Chambers singing it better. |