To Thread - Forum Home

The Mudcat Café TM
https://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=63690
38 messages

BS: The Doctor returns!!!!

15 Oct 03 - 12:45 PM (#1036215)
Subject: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: GUEST

Who!


15 Oct 03 - 02:35 PM (#1036225)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: Mickey191

a click on who got me> "The publisher refuses to give you accsess to this page." Why?


15 Oct 03 - 02:49 PM (#1036235)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: McGrath of Harlow

Richard Grant would be my choice for the Doctor.


15 Oct 03 - 03:28 PM (#1036259)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: Clinton Hammond

I wonder if Tom Baker would come back...

Gods know, he needs the work!

LOL


15 Oct 03 - 03:58 PM (#1036270)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: Mark Clark

Aha! The Master will get his final comeuppance at last. Or he may alread have gotten at stome time in the future.

Many years ago I used to visit The World's Biggest Bookstore in Toronto and the largest section in this very large bookstore was devoted entirely to Dr. Who. It was the first time I realized it had gone so far beyond the original programme.

      - Mark


15 Oct 03 - 04:11 PM (#1036277)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: DonMeixner

I liked Paul McGann(?) just fine as The Doctor but I could see:

Michael J. Pollard (quirky)
Peter O'Toole (Regal)
Richard Briers (Just a bit Daffy)
Bruce Campbell (Just cuz)
A few guys in "The Full Monty" (The security guard especially)

The actor who playe Captain Pellew in the recent "Hornnblower" series would certainly get my vote.

Don


15 Oct 03 - 04:34 PM (#1036292)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: PageOfCups

My question is, will Daleks ever learn to climb stairs?

PoC


15 Oct 03 - 04:35 PM (#1036294)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: Clinton Hammond

" Bruce Campbell (Just cuz)"

Oh ye gods NOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!

:-)


15 Oct 03 - 05:57 PM (#1036349)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: Dr. Guitar

Indeed dear friends he has never been away!

Yours most sincerely,

Dr. Guitar


15 Oct 03 - 06:00 PM (#1036351)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: Wesley S

For those of us in the states - tell us who Who was.


15 Oct 03 - 06:53 PM (#1036391)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: akenaton

Just a wee preen.   Kent Smith....aka Sylvestre McCoy the seventh Doctor was in my class..3A2 in Dunoon Grammar School    1961.
   Ake..


15 Oct 03 - 08:37 PM (#1036465)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: GUEST

Sir Derek Jacobi would make an excellent Doc Who


15 Oct 03 - 08:39 PM (#1036467)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: Rt Revd Sir jOhn from Hull

It should be Patrick Moore, [that space bloke, with the broken glasses].


15 Oct 03 - 08:49 PM (#1036470)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: GUEST,ozmacca

Out here in Oz, our ABC started running the original Doctor Who series at 6.00pm Monday to Thursday (family prime time) about three weeks back - starting with the very first. And not before time.......... It's great to see them again, and the Doctor may very well be a sixties icon, but oh dear, the old cardboard and string special effects don't stand up too well these days.

I'll be interested to see how long it takes us to get a brand new series down-under. Usually the automatic taste-oriented anti-gravity system seems to cut in and stop anything half-decent trickling down the globe while letting the garbage through.


15 Oct 03 - 09:10 PM (#1036477)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: Mark Clark

I don't think a new Dr. Who series would be very entertaining without “the old cardboard and string special effects” ozmacca mentined. That was what made it such a hoot, horribly bad costumes and special effects together with sharp wit on the part of writers and actors.

In the early 1950s, U.S. television featured a character called Captain Video. The sets, costumes and effects were very like those from Dr. Who. What distinguished Captain Video was that the writing and acting was every bit the equal of the costumes and sets…dreadful.

      - Mark


15 Oct 03 - 09:37 PM (#1036487)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: Bill D

Dr. Who is available in the US on NPR in many areas, but I could never get into it...you either follow it religiously and adopt the mindset necessary to suspend critical thinking, or you just wrinkle your brow and ask "what IS this?"

I know both sorts.


15 Oct 03 - 11:47 PM (#1036548)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: GUEST,ozmacca

Bill D, I AM both sorts........ I like the Doctor (well, most of them), and I liked most of the plot lines, and many of the supporting actors. Even some of the scripts were acceptable, but as Mark said, the cardboard and string non-effects and shoestring budget made it entertainment rather than "real" sci-fi. Shame really, for the idea could have made good sci-fi, but it would have cost far too much for the BBC to produce, even if they had wanted to. It only made it off the ground because it started as children's TV. Having said all that, I'd still watch it for the entertainment value, even if I am saying "What IS this?".


15 Oct 03 - 11:57 PM (#1036550)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: DonMeixner

Patrick McGoohan would do well too. I like Derek Jacobi very much too.

Strange to say I think my favorite was Patrick Traughton tho' I liked Pertwee very much and Tom Baker was wonderfull as well.

Don


16 Oct 03 - 12:26 AM (#1036554)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: katlaughing

Wesley, by now I've guess you've figured out Who they are talking about, eh?:-)

I never could get into, but Rog and the kids sure did. My son used to tell the girls the big cloth swishing things at the auto. car wash were the "Bumonji"(sp) coming to get them. To this day whenever any of us goes through one we laugh about it.

Rog says he can just see Boy George as Time Queen. And, he figured David Bowie would play the good Doctor.:-)


16 Oct 03 - 12:28 AM (#1036555)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: katlaughing

Another one we both like: Laurence Whateverhisnameis on Changing Rooms would make a great Dr. Who...he's got the flair and decorating sense!**bg**


16 Oct 03 - 02:44 AM (#1036574)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: C-flat

Well the Tardis could do with a make-over and Llewelyn-Bowen could come up with imaginative ways to make such a small space appear bigger.


16 Oct 03 - 05:49 AM (#1036636)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: Dave Bryant

I could think of a few suggestions for the doctor:

Alan Davies
Peter Firth
(as a sort of middle-aged Dominick Hide)
on the other hand if he could change sex when he regenerates, I could imagine either Toyah Willcocks or perhaps Caroline Quin as the doctor.

Perhaps the TARDIS could do with an external update now that police telephone boxes have all but disappeared. I often wondered why it was chosen to blend in with the landscape when so many landings were on strange planets or different time periods - what about making it look like one of those Superloos ?


16 Oct 03 - 08:21 AM (#1036687)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: Grab

PoC, afraid it's already happened. They've got kind of hovercraft bits on their underneath.


16 Oct 03 - 10:30 AM (#1036777)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: muppett

Remember Nigel who used to be in Eastenders, you know he went to go & live in Scotland and Dot keeps going to visit him, well he'd make a brill Doctor.

Oh & Page of cups, the daleks have already learnt to climb stairs, they did it years ago, keep up.


16 Oct 03 - 10:32 AM (#1036778)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: Sandra in Sydney

Dave, as I remember it the Tardis was supposed to change in each landscape but something got stuck (maybe it was the lack of money that led to that storyline!).

We got TV in 1966 when I was 14 & I saw some episodes over the next 10 years before I moved out (probably not many as I never did watch much TV) & loved it. I used to read the novelisations to get my fix. I have several commemorative books, the Radio Times Special for the 10th anniversary & the BBC 20th Anniversary special, and a hardcover book by Peter Haining also for the 20th anniversary, 1983.

The last episode I (supposedly) saw was when Tom Baker's doctor was regenerating as the Peter Davison Doctor - "supposedly" as my brother's old TV had a bad case of something or other - I don't think it recovered - and the pictures rolled & ghosted so badly that there were 4 companions carrying 2 Doctors when I had to turn it off, it was driving me crazy trying to see what was really happening.

Looks like I might have to cultivate TV owning friends (JennyO?)

sandra


16 Oct 03 - 10:40 AM (#1036786)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: sian, west wales

{{{e-hem}}}

Please note: BBC WALES!

(yea, Wales! hip, hip ...)

I've heard the name Eddie Izzard mentioned but I think maybe Sian Phillips or Penelope Keith ...

sian


16 Oct 03 - 10:42 AM (#1036788)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: katlaughing

Caroline Quinn would make a brill Dr.! Diana Rigg might, too.:-) And, who was the actress that did the serious bit as the writer? Oh, geez can't believe I've forgotten, she (the writer) was hell to live with, had a lesbian affair or so her husband thought...not Virginia Wolff. Anyway, the actress was magnificent and has the heighth and angularity to do a great Dr. I'll go find out who she was.

Thanks c-flat, I couldn't remember "Llewelyn-Bowen."


16 Oct 03 - 10:52 AM (#1036795)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: JennyO

Sandra: Knock knock

Jenny: Who's there?

Sandra: Doctor

Jenny: Doctor Who?

Sandra: Doctor Who on channel two.



So Sandra, is it to be quiet nights sitting watching TV in our lounge room from now on, instead of sessions?



BTW, stepped on any good CD's lately? :-)


Jenny


16 Oct 03 - 11:42 AM (#1036831)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: Mark Clark

The TARDIS (acronym for Time And Relative Dimension In Space) looked like a London police box on the outside because it's chameleon system broke in an early episode (the first?) and it was stuck looking that way. It would seem a shame to repair the chameleon for a new series since that bit of lore was a main pice of shtik.

I really can't see the point of a Dr. Who series looking like one of the many Star Trek sequels. What would be the point? That's already been done and redone. No, we'll have to stay with the cardboard and string.

      - Mark


16 Oct 03 - 02:18 PM (#1036930)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: PageOfCups

Thanks for the update on the Daleks. It's been awhile since I've seen the show - the PBS outlet I used to watch it on must have skipped the season with the hovering Daleks.

Speaking of which, I wonder how long the new episodes will take to trickle down to PBS here in San Diego? And will they be able to shoehorn them in between the endless Lawrence Welk, Andre Rieu, and John Bradshaw repeats during their nearly-monthly begathons? Maybe it's time to shell out for digital cable so I can get the BBC...

PoC


16 Oct 03 - 02:57 PM (#1036953)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: Firecat

My vote to play the Doctor would be either Hugh Laurie or Stephen Fry!

I was 5 when it was cancelled, but I've seen loads of them on video. McCoy and Davison are my favourites, with Tom Baker a close third.


16 Oct 03 - 04:11 PM (#1036993)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: DonMeixner

Penelope Keith Or Felicity Kendall.

:-)

Don


16 Oct 03 - 05:35 PM (#1037041)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: radriano

I seem to remember a not too long ago movie version of Dr. Who that was pretty slick.

I like the concept of Dr. Who but I also have trouble with the cheesy effects and soap opera type production the show usually gets.


18 Oct 03 - 11:26 AM (#1037714)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: Sandra in Sydney

It wouldn't be the same with a big budget - let's get back to vinyl covered kitchen chairs in Ancient Rome.

My favourite bookmark (copyright 1977) shows Mona Lisa in overalls holding a spanner & says The best man for the job is often a woman, something I've agreed with since my first job in 1970 when I sat next to another school leaver who got 25% more money that me cos he was male.

BUT I still want to see a male Dr Who! If it was all SFX & 2003 instead of 1963, it wouldn't be the Dr Who we all knew & loved.


18 Oct 03 - 12:56 PM (#1037736)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: McGrath of Harlow

Someone who would be great as the Doctor is Paul Bradley, whom Americans will never have heard of - he played a character cxalled Nigel Bates in the soap Eastenders, which he left a few years ago.

Here's a link to a page about that, with a couple of photos of him.

He's also a folk performer of sorts - lead singer with a strange occasional band called hKippers.


18 Oct 03 - 01:00 PM (#1037739)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: Herga Kitty

Paul McGann did a one-off feature, not a series (it was shown in England on a Whitsun/ May Bank Holiday Monday, and I remember leaving Bampton early to catch it). The TV series were faithful to the concept of the Doctor "ageing backwards" and the actors who played the Doctor being (well, at least looking) younger in each successive series. This would rule out most of the candidates nominated above....

Kitty


18 Oct 03 - 01:24 PM (#1037745)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: McGrath of Harlow

THtablink to Paul Bradley wasn't right - this is

Ageing backwards - I never came across that rule. Imagine it, the Doctor as a stroppy teenage Dr Who. My namesake, Kevin the Teenager in Harry Enfield perhaps... Mind it might be a nigbtmare, but it'd be gripping stuff. Can't see the BBC having the nerve to do it though.


18 Oct 03 - 05:18 PM (#1037808)
Subject: RE: BS: The Doctor returns!!!!
From: McGrath of Harlow

I did it again - I put an extra quotation mark in the link for Kevin and it didn't work. (IT'S NOT FAIR!!!) So I'll do that post again:

That link to Paul Bradley wasn't right - this is.

Ageing backwards - I never came across that rule. Imagine it, the Doctor as a stroppy teenage Dr Who. My namesake, Kevin the Teenager, courtesy Harry Enfield, perhaps... Mind it might be a nigbtmare, but it'd be gripping stuff. Can't see the BBC having the nerve to do it though.