To Thread - Forum Home

The Mudcat Café TM
https://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=67443
21 messages

Your fav audience dumb question/remark

29 Feb 04 - 01:55 PM (#1126278)
Subject: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: GUEST,Len Wallace

Hi again Mudcattenaners,

It happened to me again last night, performing in an Irish pub in Windsor.

I was performing with my trio, The Diggers. Sat down for our first break. A member of another band joined us for a brew. Onstage walks a young woman who says, "You gotta play 'Piano Man'! It's my favourite Irish song!"

Need I say more?

Would like to hear your stories.

Len Wallace


29 Feb 04 - 03:37 PM (#1126337)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: Maurice Mann

My favourite was at a session with Yorkshire Garland (a great Irish band) at Whitby Festival some years ago.

Audience question: "What's the best way to play a bodhran"
Band reply: "With a penknife"


29 Feb 04 - 03:47 PM (#1126341)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: Clinton Hammond

Asked in the pisser, by a guy who I'd been talking with from the stage...

"So, do you play here?"

*?*

heh


29 Feb 04 - 09:10 PM (#1126557)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: Walking Eagle

I was playing with a pick-up band at Mallory Square in Key West at sunset one evening.

Tennessee Williams had an apartment/house there at the time. He was still alive then, I believe. Some dude walks up to us during a break and says 'Play something by Tennessee Williams.' I KID YOU NOT! We said 'Sure, just put something in the offering cup first.' This chump of a dude does as instructed. We put our heads together--whisper, whisper. We finally nodded our heads and, right there on the spot, ripped into a song whose sole lyric was 'Stella!' We played in blues style!

There's one born every moment. This one just happened our way with $100.00 to blow.


29 Feb 04 - 09:41 PM (#1126574)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: Dave Hanson

At a supposedly Irish session at McCrorys bar in Bradford, ' do you know any Atomic Kitten ? '
Well it is close to the university.
eric


29 Feb 04 - 09:51 PM (#1126580)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: Walking Eagle

C.H. LOL!


01 Mar 04 - 03:19 AM (#1126708)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: GUEST

I once had a giant Canuk with muklucks and a coon skin cap ask me if I could play "The Maple Leaf Forever"

"Nah," I said, "I get jacked off with it after twenty minutes."


01 Mar 04 - 06:16 AM (#1126805)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: Mr Happy

my mate Jim, who plays 5 string banjo is frequently asked to do 'Duelling Banjos'- as a solo?

punters often call it 'Gillian's or Julian's Banjos' too!


01 Mar 04 - 06:53 AM (#1126828)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: GUEST,Mappa Mundi

I was sitting in a pub playing guitar and singing. The plurk sitting opposite me, leaned over and said; "Have you got a light mate"? - I was only halfway through the song!!!!!


01 Mar 04 - 07:36 AM (#1126851)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: Cluin

Clinton, the answer of course is: "No, I work here."


01 Mar 04 - 07:43 AM (#1126855)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: Splott Man

Yesterday teatime, in a pub in Swansea, having just finished nearly 2 hours of classic Americana (Hank Williams, Woody etc etc), we were in the final stages of packing away the PA when this fellow asked us to back him on Great balls of Fire.

I can almost see his logic


01 Mar 04 - 07:48 AM (#1126860)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: Midchuck

Mr. Happy, I do have a very old vinyl of a very young Jose Feliciano playing "Dueling Banjos" as a solo, on one guitar, no multitrack tricks.

Of course, I'm not Jose Feliciano, and I doubt your friend is either, but it has been done.

I think he plays "Flight of the Bumblebee" as a guitar solo on the same album.

Peter.


01 Mar 04 - 07:52 AM (#1126863)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: Dave the Gnome

Accoustic session and singaround in a pub in the Yorkshire Dales, mid February. In walk the local superbrains...

"Give us Bohemian Rhapsody"

Honest!

Cheers

DtG


01 Mar 04 - 08:12 AM (#1126876)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: JennyO

Martin Pearson, master purveyor of wit, amusing anecdotes and very funny songs, tells of the drunk who called out:

"Dju do requests?"

Martin: "No."

Drunk: "Good. Dju do Tchooubular Bells?"


01 Mar 04 - 08:13 AM (#1126877)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: Morticia

We were playing a gig in a local pub once when the young lad-about-town asks if his girlfriend can come and do a number with us because she has, allegedly and I quote, " A well good voice".So we obligingly invite her up, only to witness her utter chagrin and shock that we don't have, and once again I quote " the words on a little screen". She thought my music stand contained some sort of karaoke device.....bless.


01 Mar 04 - 08:40 AM (#1126893)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: Davetnova

Well some of these would be serious requests to some catters. At the recent North Yorkshire gather Geoff the Duck gave us Duelling Banjos as a solo piece an Muppitz gave us Bohemian Rhapsody (Curry Rhadsody anyway).Both went down extremely well


01 Mar 04 - 08:42 AM (#1126894)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: Rapparee

I've always liked the Clancys concert where they asked, "Can you hear us?" Voices from the audience replied, "Noooo!" Response: "Those who couldn't hear us -- how did you know what we were saying?"


01 Mar 04 - 09:44 AM (#1126947)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: Ross

I went to see '2001 - a space odyssey' at the cinema with a friend

At the point where the computer (AI) HAL goes mad and turns the life support off, to three sleeping astronauts

Ten foot computer high letters on computer terminals blink 'LIFE TERMINATED'

My friend shouted in a tense hushed packed cinema

ARE THEY DEAD THEN?


01 Mar 04 - 05:50 PM (#1127268)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: Art Thieme

I always felt rather kindly toward folks who did this. They knew very little about a particular topic and wanted to know more but didn't know enough about it to frame a good beginning question. You just need to get very basic with your answer---and then build a bit from there. But it's always tempting to use what seems like a dumb question as a way to bond with your cohorts and guffaw out loud at the hapless soul. After I'd been playing about ten years on a Mississippi River steamboat, a passenger asked me a question that took me aback. Keep in mind that most of the folks who rode these boats came a long way to do it---often from other continents. Big plans had to be made and there were usually big reasons why they wanted to spend days out on the fabled Mississippi. A fellow who seemed like a rather nice guy asked one morning:

"What is this body of water named?"

As far as he knew we were on Lake Michigan or the Gulf Of Mexico or the Bay Of Fundy. It did become the perfect sad question for the crew to snicker at and shake their heads over that year.

Art Thieme


01 Mar 04 - 09:23 PM (#1127392)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: The Dane

Mine gotta be from a friend of mine who was playihng an Irish Pub in Germany one night. A woman came up to the stage and asked him to play "Happy Birthday". He goes: "OK, who's the birthday boy?", to which she replies: "Nobody, I just like the song!"


02 Mar 04 - 03:01 PM (#1127899)
Subject: RE: Your fav audience dumb question/remark
From: Mr Happy

Midchuck,

I'm able to play 'Duelling Banjos' on my melodeon, as a solo,by alternating with trebles & basses- but I'm never requested to do it-sob!