To Thread - Forum Home

The Mudcat Café TM
https://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=68917
15 messages

Touching Evil (USA Cable TV Show)

18 Apr 04 - 12:39 AM (#1164175)
Subject: Touching Evil (USA Cable TV Show)
From: wysiwyg

Excellent newer drama. Friday evenings 10 PM eastern time, repeats Saturday midmorning, on USA Cable Network.

Anyone else?

I have a GREAT idea for an alternative show premise-- make him the cold-case detective who solves all of the unsolved murders he himself left cold. (Start off with some really bad old baddie whose been underground but has come back to taunt him now that he's back on the job but impaired.)

Now that he's had his brain altered by that injury that interferes with his self-censorship, he can see things he missed back then, as if they are painted in neon. Doing these stories would involve him playing 2 characters in each show-- the self he is now and the person he WAS, in flashbacks. How cool would THAT be?

~S~


18 Apr 04 - 05:04 AM (#1164222)
Subject: RE: Touching Evil (USA Cable TV Show)
From: Strollin' Johnny

Hey there WYSIWYG, isn't this the rather gory BRITISH detective-mystery-thingy that we saw here about two years ago? Stars a Scottish or Irish actor whose name I've forgotten, but who always plays detectives with mental/marital/attitude problems?
Johnny :0)


18 Apr 04 - 09:41 AM (#1164356)
Subject: RE: Touching Evil (USA Cable TV Show)
From: Greg F.

Not exactly, Johnny- its a rip-off & pastiche of the much better done British Version with D.I. Dave Creegan-played by Robson Greenwith- reconstituted for a US Audience.

Must to Avoid- watch the original.


18 Apr 04 - 10:13 AM (#1164369)
Subject: RE: Touching Evil (USA Cable TV Show)
From: ranger1

We yanks actually get to see the original British version on Public Television. Mystery usually runs it every so often. I like the original so much that I won't watch the American version (even if I had cable).


18 Apr 04 - 10:41 AM (#1164384)
Subject: RE: Touching Evil (USA Cable TV Show)
From: katlaughing

I agree with GregF and ranger1. I love watching Robson Green act in anything and I cannot even imagine that anyone could ever play the character better. I won't even watch the imitation. Why does American TV do that, anyway? Lack of creativity or pure lazyness?


18 Apr 04 - 10:57 AM (#1164396)
Subject: RE: Touching Evil (USA Cable TV Show)
From: Richard Bridge

Robson Greene? Act? Try "Cracker" with Coltrane. Now he can act.


18 Apr 04 - 11:20 AM (#1164416)
Subject: RE: Touching Evil (USA Cable TV Show)
From: wysiwyg

I think you might give it a try. I've never seen the original. This is pretty good though, on its own.

~Susan


18 Apr 04 - 12:40 PM (#1164467)
Subject: RE: Touching Evil (USA Cable TV Show)
From: Strollin' Johnny

Yep Greg, Robson Green it was! I'd got Ken Stott in mind - nothing like Robson Green! Anyway you transatlantic types, I've seen some of your TV shows - watch the British version and learn. I'll get back to me cave now..........
Johnny :0)


18 Apr 04 - 12:40 PM (#1164468)
Subject: RE: Touching Evil (USA Cable TV Show)
From: Metchosin

Richard, I would agree with you regarding Coltrane, although I found some of the episodes of Touching Evil with Greene to be quite gripping and very well done. As yet, nobody can touch the Brits when it comes to mysteries and drama. Remakes in the US might get the storyline correct, but seem to be unable to develop any real humanity or depth of character in the protagonists, something always gets lost in translation. Perhaps it is the lack of interesting female characters that is one of the stumbling points, there don't seem to be any equivalents of Helen Mirren or Zoe Wanamaker in the US.


18 Apr 04 - 02:03 PM (#1164517)
Subject: RE: Touching Evil (USA Cable TV Show)
From: katlaughing

I agree also about Coltrane,esp. in Cracker, but I love what Green (on his official website there is no "e" at the end) brings to his characters, very much.


19 Apr 04 - 07:40 AM (#1165079)
Subject: RE: Touching Evil (USA Cable TV Show)
From: Strollin' Johnny

Perhaps its to do with the fact that the Brits use brain to solve problems whereas Americans just shout at them (ER being a point in question, in the UK I've never seen sick people made better by a horde in hospital uniforms running around like headless chickens and shouting meaningless drivel as loudly as possible at them)! :0) :0)

I'll get back to my cave then.....................

Johnny :0)


19 Apr 04 - 10:47 AM (#1165219)
Subject: RE: Touching Evil (USA Cable TV Show)
From: GUEST

The US seems to have an entire industry centered around taking British TV shows and re-creating them as poor knock-offs for many times the cost and with sensational lack of success.


19 Apr 04 - 02:26 PM (#1165439)
Subject: RE: Touching Evil (USA Cable TV Show)
From: Strick

"I think you might give it a try. I've never seen the original. This is pretty good though, on its own."

I've seen the original, Susan, and could never get into it. This is a much better Americanization than what they did to Cracker. I've enjoyed it quite a bit.


19 Apr 04 - 02:32 PM (#1165449)
Subject: RE: Touching Evil (USA Cable TV Show)
From: wysiwyg

But I refuse to go see the new "Cheaper by the Dozen." (shudder)

I hated Cracker!

And we saw Cold Case last night for the first and LAST time.

~S~


19 Apr 04 - 02:33 PM (#1165452)
Subject: RE: Touching Evil (USA Cable TV Show)
From: GUEST,MMario

Considering a have a cousin who married into the family of 'Cheaper By the Dozen' I *definately* do not wish to see it.