|
26 Nov 98 - 05:55 PM (#46887) Subject: Recruiting Sergeant From: Philippa Here's the last verse. Am seeking the rest and the 19th c. song that this version of around 1916 may be based on. And does An Gabhar Bán (recorded by Clannad) go to the same air? (Somebody asked me if it did.) Come wind or rain or hail or snow We’re not going out to Flanders oh When there’s fighting in Dublin to be done Let the sergeants and commanders go. Let Englishmen for England fight It's just about time they started oh And I wished them all a very good night And there and then we parted oh. |
|
26 Nov 98 - 06:59 PM (#46897) Subject: RE: Recruiting Sergeant From: Martin Ryan. Sounds as though its based on "The Banha Peeler"? Regards |
|
26 Nov 98 - 07:14 PM (#46898) Subject: RE: Recruiting Sergeant From: Brack& It was written by Seamus O'Farrell in 1915, and that all I know!! Anyone caught singing it was liable to six months imprisonment. I don't know it meself, but I'll have a look round, I may have it on vinyl somewhere. Regards Mick Braken. |
|
26 Nov 98 - 07:15 PM (#46899) Subject: RE: Recruiting Sergeant From: Martin Ryan. Correction: "The Bansha Peeler" - about a 19C. policeman given to arresting goats! Regards |
|
26 Nov 98 - 07:18 PM (#46900) Subject: RE: Recruiting Sergeant From: Martin Ryan. Philippa ... and given that "An Gabhar Ban" means the "white goat" - there may well be a connection! Don't know the song, mind you.
Regards |
|
29 Nov 98 - 02:38 PM (#47199) Subject: Lyr Add: THE RECRUITING SERGEANT (from The Pogues) From: Parable Jones Our ceilidh band managed to work this song into a strip the willow. Here are the full lyrics: THE RECRUITING SERGEANT As recorded by The Pogues on "If I Should Fall from Grace with God" (1988) As I was walking down the road A-feeling fine and larky oh, A recruiting sergeant came up to me. Says he: "You'd look fine in khaki oh, For the king he is in need of men. Come and read this proclamation oh. A life in Flanders for you then Would be a fine vacation oh." "That may be so," says I to him, "But tell me, sergeant dearie oh, If I had a pack stuck up on my back Would I look fine and cheery oh? For they'd have you train and drill Until they had you like the Frenchies oh. It may be warm in Flanders, It's draughty in the trenches oh." The sergeant smiled and winked his eye. His smile was most provoking oh. He twiddled and twirled his wee mustache. Says he: "You're only joking oh. The sandbags are so warm and high The wind you won’t feel blowing oh." I winked at a colleen passing by. Says I: "What if it's snowing oh? "Come rain or hail or wind and snow, I'm not going out to Flanders oh. There's fighting in Dublin to be done. Let your sergeants and your commanders go. Let English men fight English wars. It’s nearly time they started oh." I saluted the sergeant a very good night. There and then we parted oh. |
|
02 Dec 98 - 03:01 PM (#47670) Subject: RE: Recruiting Sergeant From: Philippa The Peeler and the Goat is on the DT (with "Penshaw" instead of "Banba"). An Gabhar Bán does have the same air and is about a drunk and disorderly goat. It's to be found on an unofficial Clannad website (www.jtwinc.com/clannad/clanhome.htm), but there are errors - expert Irish speakers are welcome to contact the site and give corrections - also to add to the Gabhar Bán thread started by Áine at Mudcat. I still have no info. on any related but earlier song about recruiting sergeants. Thanks Martin, Mick and Parable for the information and lyrics you've contributed. Mick - who was Seamus O'Farrell, i.e. what else do you know about him? |
|
05 Sep 04 - 09:43 AM (#1264674) Subject: RE: Recruiting Sergeant From: GUEST,Kathleen Seamus O'Farrell (my father) (1886-1973), a journalist, was a Dublin man. He assisted with the formation of the Irish Transport & General Workers' Union. He was very involved with nationalist movements and wrote for the "mosquito press": as one might say "he wrote when it was dangerous to write"! He worked on the staff of the Irish Independent and then the Irish Press. Later he edited the Longford Leader and the Leinster Leader. He contributed a column ("Speaking for Myself")to the Nationalist and Leinster Times during the sixties. He was a founder member of Muintir na Tire and an active member (and one-time President)of the National Agricultural and Industrial Development Association.He was a member of Seanad Eireann during the first Coalition Government. "The Recruiting Sergeant" was published in some subversive paper; it was intended to be sung to the tune of THE PEELER AND THE GOAT Regards |
|
05 Sep 04 - 12:25 PM (#1264748) Subject: Lyr Add: RECRUITING SERGEANT (from Dominic Behan) From: belfast Here are the lyrics from the singing of Dominic Behan. Not much different from the words given previously as it happens. I'm surprised it's not in the DigiTrad. The previous post notwithstanding, I was always under the impression that the song was written by Behan's uncle, Peadar Kearney. I could be wrong, of course - it's happened before. THE RECRUITING SERGEANT As recorded by Dominic Behan on "Easter Monday: Songs of the IRA" (2012) As I was going down the street, feeling fine and larky-o, A recruiting sergeant said to me: "Now you'd look fine in khaki-o. The King he is in need of men; come read his proclamation-o. A life in Flanders for you then will be a fine vacation-o." "That may be so," says I to him, "but tell me, sergeant dearie-o: If I'd a pack stuck on me back, do you think I'd look fine and cheery-o? You'd make me train and drill until you had me one of French's-o. It may be warm in Flanders but it's draughty in the trenches-o." The sergeant swung his wee-bit cane; his smile was most provoking-o. He twiddled and twiddled his wee mustache; says he: "I know you're joking-o. The sandbags are so nice and high, the wind you'll ne'er feel blowing-o." But I winked at a colleen passing by; says I: "What if it's snowing-o? "Yet rain or hail or wind or snow, we're not going out to Flanders-o. There's fighting in Dublin to be done; let your sergeants and commanders go. Let Englishmen for England fight; 'tis just about time they started-o." I wished the sergeant a jolly good night and there and then we parted-o. |
|
05 Sep 04 - 10:49 PM (#1265024) Subject: RE: Recruiting Sergeant From: GUEST,Barrie Roberts It can also be found on the Smithsonian/Folkways 'Irish Rebellion Album', available from AK Press at www.akpress.com, sung by your humble correspondent. If that isn't reason enough to get the record, it also features Ian Campbell, Tommy Dempsey, Brian Clarke, Billie Campbell and a real rarity -- Harvey Andrews singing The Patriot Game |
|
06 Sep 04 - 07:11 AM (#1265159) Subject: RE: Recruiting Sergeant From: Deckman I have this fine song on a record by Robin Hall and Jimmie McGreger (sp?) Bob |
|
06 Sep 04 - 10:19 AM (#1265236) Subject: RE: Recruiting Sergeant From: Big Tim I think you're wrong on this one Belfast! But why do you suggest Kearney? The lyrics were also published in "The Rebels Ceilidh Songbook" - "as sung by Hugh MacDonald". Since this was a Scots publication, a little folkie bible for a while, it may well be where Hall and McGregor got it. Kathleen, thank you for the information about your father. Can you tell us more? It's an excellent song. |
|
06 Sep 04 - 11:19 AM (#1265284) Subject: RE: Recruiting Sergeant From: MartinRyan Big Tim It's listed in many of the Irish Book Bureau booklets, FWIW. Nothing less ephemeral that I can find for now. Regards |
|
07 Sep 04 - 05:44 AM (#1265831) Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Recruiting Sergeant From: Jim McLean Big Tim, Hugh MacDonald and his wife Agnes (who lived in Busby) were friends of mine a long time ago and we were all frequent visitors to Morris Blythman's house as were Jimmy and Robin before they moved to London. It was Morris who put together the Rebel Ceilidh Songbook. I have a photo' of Dominic Behan, his brother Rory, Hugh, Agnes and myself taken in around 1959/60 so all would know the songs sung by each other. |
|
07 Sep 04 - 09:36 AM (#1265914) Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Recruiting Sergeant From: Big Tim Ah! Jim lad, those were the days! |
|
07 Sep 04 - 10:30 AM (#1265959) Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Recruiting Sergeant From: GUEST Mea Culpa. To tell the truth the truth I've no idea where I got the notion that Kearney was the author. But the (incorrect) notion was reinforced by the similarity in tone and style to "Whack fol the diddle" and "Down by the Liffeyside". |
|
07 Sep 04 - 04:18 PM (#1266182) Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Recruiting Sergeant From: Big Tim Jim you got a date for the Rebel Song Book? Don't see it in the book itself). Who was Morris Blythman? He isn't mentioned in William Kellock's intro. (Hugh Macdonald is). Anyone know the date of the Hall/McGregor recording? And finally, I wonder where the Pogues got the song from? (Leave that one to me). |
|
07 Sep 04 - 08:26 PM (#1266390) Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Recruiting Sergeant From: Susanne (skw) John, maybe the name Thurso Berwick is more familiar to you? That was Morris's alias. From what I've read about him, he was the single moving force behind the Scottish folk revival, starting with songs about the repatriation of the Stone of Destiny and the Polaris protests. See e.g. Ailie Munro, The Democratic Muse, for more info. And maybe Jim McLean is in the mood to tell us more about him and those days ... |
|
08 Sep 04 - 04:08 AM (#1266593) Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Recruiting Sergeant From: Big Tim Thanks Susanne: I did wonder about that, Thurso and Berwick being the northern and southern extremities of Scotland (no pedants on this little geographical detail please!), an unlikely, but possible, combination. You got the "Rebel" book Susanne, if not let me know, and I'll send you a photocopy (it's a wee stoater!). |
|
09 Sep 04 - 08:32 AM (#1267515) Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Recruiting Sergeant From: belfast A previous post, unsigned and therefore meaningless, is from me. I forgot that I was cookieless. I said: 'Mea Culpa. To tell the truth the truth I've no idea where I got the notion that Kearney was the author. But the (incorrect) notion was reinforced by the similarity in tone and style to "Whack fol the diddle" and "Down by the Liffeyside"'. |
|
09 Sep 04 - 09:16 AM (#1267538) Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Recruiting Sergeant From: GUEST,Keith A o Hertford at work 6 months for singing it sounds a bit steep. Service was always voluntary in Ireland even when conscription was in full swing for the rest of the country. I would think that the greatest risk to singers was from the loved ones of the hundreds of thousands of Irishmen who were fighting for freedom in Flanders and elsewhere. Keith. |
|
28 Aug 09 - 10:00 PM (#2711272) Subject: Lyr Add: THE RECRUITING SERGEANT (from Roy Palmer) From: Q (Frank Staplin) This version is from the book by Roy Palmer, 1977, "The Rambling Soldier," Penguin Books. The Recruiting Sergeant Irish trad but from bothies of NE Scotland 1 As we were a-walking along the seaside, Oh, who did we meet but Sergeant McBride? We determined to have a bit bathe in the tide; It was on a fine summer's morning. 2 As we were a-walking along the sea sand, Now, who did we meet but Corporal Brand? And a little wee drummer called Arthur McDand, A-going to the fair in the morning. 3 "It's now, my brave fellows, if you want to enlist, It's five golden guineas I'll clap in your fist; Besides, there's five shillings to kick up a dust As you go to the fair in the morning. 4 "It's then you will also go decent and clean While all other fellows go dirty and mean; While all other fellows go dirty and mean, And sup their burgoo in the morning." 5 "Och, you need not be talking about your fine pay, For all you have got is one shilling a day; And as for your debt, the drums pay your way As you march through the town in the morning. 6 "And you need not be talking about your fine clothes, For you've just got the loan of them, as I do suppose; And you dare not sell them in spite of your nose, Or you would get flogged in the morning. 7 "I'm blest," says the sergeant, "if I'll take more of that From any coxcomb or cowfeeding brat; And if you tip me any more of that chat, I will run you through in the morning." 8 But before they had time to pull out their blades Our whacking shillelaghs came over their heads, And we did teach them that we were their blades To dampen their rage in the morning. 9 As for the wee drummer, we diddled his pow, And made a footbll of his rowdidedow; And into the tide we did make him to row, Then we bade them a' good morning. This version, "'a shilling a day,' must date the song to the nineteenth century." With brief musical score. |
|
31 Aug 09 - 12:49 PM (#2712997) Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Recruiting Sergeant From: GUEST,Tiddler That's not a version - it's a completely different song (which has nothing to do with this thread). |
|
02 Sep 09 - 12:44 PM (#2714671) Subject: Lyr Add: THE RECRUITING SERGEANT From: Jim Dixon The song that Q posted above is a version of ARTHUR McBRIDE or ARTHUR McBRIDE AND THE SERGEANT, which are in the DT, with links to several threads. This one is from The Universal Songster: Or, Museum of Mirth, Volume 3 (London: Jones and Co., 1834) page 379: THE RECRUITING SERGEANT. Air—"Darby Kelly." WHEN first I heard the drum and fife Strike up a march so neatly, O! I thought I never in my life, Heard music sound so sweetly, O; The soldiers they in coats so gay, Retreating and advancing, too; With martial air, to win the fair, It set my heart a-dancing, too; Brown Bess I seized, the girls were pleased, I looked so smart, you don't know how, They laughed and cried, and sighed and died, When first I joined the row-dow-dow. But when no joke at all they found, But that I must be going, O! In tears they every one were drowned, Their grief so overflowing, O! But off I went, abroad was sent, The mounseers fought so finely, too; With blows and bumps, and whacks and thumps. We paid 'em so divinely, too; While cannon-shot flew thick and hot Such sport it was, you don't know how, Upon that day to cut and slay, And all to the tune of row-dow-dow. So well I liked the notion, Of guns, and wounds, and all that there, I quickly got promotion, And now my sword and halberd bear; Then every lad must sure be glad, On terms like these with me to list, Here's glorious fame, a hero's name, Besides ten guineas in your fist; Which, if you live, will pleasure give, And if you die, you don't know how, Your praise 'twill raise, to end your days. And all to the tune of row-dow-dow. |
|
02 Sep 09 - 04:17 PM (#2714887) Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Recruiting Sergeant From: ard mhacha Philippa, here is very good recording of this song, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ob6P493tJko |
|
02 Sep 09 - 05:54 PM (#2714957) Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Recruiting Sergeant From: Q (Frank Staplin) "Arthur McBride" was collected as "The Recruiting Sergeant" by John Ord, "Bothy Songs and Ballads.". The latter name is used by Palmer in his "The Rambling Soldier," his collection of "songs of the lower ranks," published by Penguin Books, England, 1977. Both names are used for the song. |
|
24 Mar 16 - 07:08 PM (#3780938) Subject: The Recruiting Sergeant-The Levellers From: gillymor In case you missed it. Best video I've seen in a while. Warning: Contains some blood and gore near the end but also some nice banjo and accordion work. Click here |
|
24 Mar 16 - 08:05 PM (#3780949) Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Recruiting Sergeant From: Joe Offer I moved you over to an existing "Recruiting Sergeant" thread, gillymor, but I'm not sure it's the same song. This one has a chorus that includes "over the mountains and over the sea" "picture in my pocket that means everything to me." I couldn't find a song posted here with those phrases. Anybody got time to transcribe the Levellers recording? -Joe- |
|
24 Mar 16 - 08:31 PM (#3780955) Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Recruiting Sergeant From: gillymor You're right, Joe, the one that I linked to was a contemporary "Recruiting Sergeant" by The Levellers and was quite different from the Pogues or Dubliners version. I posted because I found the video quite moving and the music infectious but I wasn't going for a Lyr Req or a Lyr Add but perhaps tomorrow I'll post the lyrics if I can find them. Thanks. |
|
25 Mar 16 - 02:44 AM (#3780999) Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Recruiting Sergeant From: Joe Offer Hi, Gillymor - seems to me that this thread would be a good place for posting the lyrics of the Levellers recording. I swear I've heard this song before, but I couldn't find it just now. Once you post the lyrics, no doubt it will all come clear and I will be banging my head against the wall once again, lamenting my stupidity. -Joe- |
|
25 Mar 16 - 09:05 AM (#3781072) Subject: Lyr Add: THE RECRUITING SERGEANT (The Levellers) From: gillymor THE RECRUITING SERGEANT As recorded by the Levellers on their EP “The Recruiting Sergeant” (in support of War Child)
CHORUS: Over the mountains and over the sea,
1. So I've fixed-up the alarm and broken halfway in, CHORUS: I was over the mountains...[etc.]
2. I know I let you down, babe, trying to make ends meet, CHORUS: And I was over the mountains...[etc.]
3. Now I'm sucking dust in Helmand, dug into Lashkar Gar, CHORUS: it's blowing over the mountains...[etc.]
4. Don't follow me to die, boys, in bloody Kandahar, CHORUS: Run over the mountains...[etc.] CHORUS: And it's over the mountains...[etc.] It's your picture in my pocket that means everything to me. - - -
Here are the words from the Levellers EP which vary slightly from the video. This one seems to be a modern take on the "Recruiting Sergeant" song tradition. |
|
26 Mar 16 - 08:32 AM (#3781394) Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Recruiting Sergeant From: Fergie The confusion concerning the authorship of The Recruiting Sergeant may arise because Peader Kearney wrote an anti-recruiting song the title of which was Sergeant William Bailey. Kearney's nephew Dominic Behan was known to sing both of these songs and I suspect that somewhere along the line Kearney's name became mistakenly associated with The Recruiting Sergeant. |
|
26 Mar 16 - 10:45 AM (#3781421) Subject: RE: Lyr Req: Recruiting Sergeant From: Keith A of Hertford An excellent song and video, but you do not meet recruiting sergeants on the street any more. |