To Thread - Forum Home

The Mudcat Café TM
https://mudcat.org/thread.cfm?threadid=85329
21 messages

A new guitar! Any suggestions?

10 Oct 05 - 11:29 AM (#1580144)
Subject: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: GUEST,jose alberto

Hi , I´ll buy a new guitar next month and have been thinking about which one should be the best option.I´ve already got a Taylor, 6 strings, and a resophonic(Johnson).As I like to play more acoustic blues and fingerstyle and I´m really in doubt , among so many models, a Martin?, or a cheaper model (cost/benefit), a Stella(tradition).
Any suggestion guys?
    thanks
         Joe


10 Oct 05 - 11:44 AM (#1580158)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: John MacKenzie

Very much an individual choice Joe, get into the music shops, play a few, buy the one you like the most at the price you can afford. Anyway you've got a couple to be going on with so if you fall in love with a really eaxpensive one you can save up and still have a guitar or two to play.
Giok


10 Oct 05 - 11:46 AM (#1580164)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: Midchuck

Did you start this thread on purpose, just to stir things up, or do you mean it?

As I like to play more acoustic blues and fingerstyle and I�m really in doubt , among so many models, a Martin?

If you can find one, I would strongly suggest trying a Martin 000-15S.

This is a 000-size (substantially smaller than a dreadnought, which many people now seem to think of as the "standard" size, but still fairly big), 12-frets to the body, slothead, made entirely of solid mahogany, including the top. It's one of Martin's cheaper models (which doesn't mean it's cheap, by any means, but you should get a new one for under a thousand US, or used down as low as 600) and I've seen a lot of good things written about it by blues pickers.

Peter.


10 Oct 05 - 11:56 AM (#1580175)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: Wesley S

How much do you have to spend ?


10 Oct 05 - 12:30 PM (#1580207)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: Strollin' Johnny

Everything Giok said. He's exactly right.
S:0)


10 Oct 05 - 12:40 PM (#1580217)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: Strollin' Johnny

Not exactly right - Giok said "Play a few", I'd say "Play a lot". Otherwise we concur. :-)
S:0)


10 Oct 05 - 01:28 PM (#1580260)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: Clinton Hammond

Seagull


10 Oct 05 - 01:31 PM (#1580264)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: Richard Bridge

If you really want a blues sound, try the ladderframe Gibsons, preferably old, but if you can't get an old one, try the Robert Johnson endorsement model - but don't expect a modern guitar sound, it will be blues sound.

The only way really is to try. And be prepared to listen blind too.


10 Oct 05 - 01:49 PM (#1580281)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: number 6

Taylor

sIx


10 Oct 05 - 02:04 PM (#1580293)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: Mooh

Play 'em all, as often as you can, for as long as you can resist buying. When you buy, have the right balance of playability, tone and timbre, durability, and appearance to suit you. Remember that the appearance is somewhat like the automobile's colour in that it matters nought when you're going 130km/hr or are being broadsided by a truck. Unless you want a simple backup axe, don't buy one that sounds like your other(s), but one that compliments you and your desired sound.

Peace, Mooh.


10 Oct 05 - 04:20 PM (#1580425)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: GUEST,jose alberto

Thanks for the input folks.I really mean it Peter, though I know it brings a lot of controvesy.I intend to try several, but maybe with some idea of models in mind not to get soooo lost.I´d rather spend no more than 1200$, but you all know that sometimes,we get betrayed by our intentions.I´ve already heard of the 000-series, but never played anyone(Who knows?)
                Joe


10 Oct 05 - 04:43 PM (#1580442)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: M.Ted

As I said on another, guitar purchase related thread, Jose, there are three price ranges for the adult musican: My Credit Card LImit, My Tax Refund, and My Uncle Died--


10 Oct 05 - 04:54 PM (#1580447)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: Clinton Hammond

"I´d rather spend no more than 1200$"

For that kinda money you can get 2 really good Seagulls!


10 Oct 05 - 05:32 PM (#1580476)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: GUEST

Remember, you get what you pay for. For $1200 you can get a really good Larrivee.


10 Oct 05 - 07:01 PM (#1580547)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: number 6

$1200 cdn ... no way.

sIx


11 Oct 05 - 11:17 AM (#1581004)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: GUEST,jose alberto

Any info about Seagulls, Blueridge, Tanglewood, Godin, Breedlove?
Is it suitable for blues and fingerstyle?
    Joe


11 Oct 05 - 11:55 AM (#1581022)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: GUEST,punkfolkrocker

an Art of Lutherie solid cedar top with a DIY fitted Kent Armstrong
[or cheaper Guitarfetish]neck screwed jazz humbucker

http://www.wdmusic.com/pickups_for_jazz_13624_ctg.htm


and a Seagull 12 string..

both together would be a very versatile and cost effective choice


11 Oct 05 - 11:57 AM (#1581025)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: Grab

Hang on - you've got a resonator, but you want something to play fingerstyle blues guitar on? Is something wrong with this picture...?

If you want a more woody blues sound, just for variety, there's no need to spend much money. But a Taylor should be versatile enough to play blues on.

Instead, why not get something that's different from the other two, like a 12-string? Plenty of good blues players used them. And that'll give you an instrument with a completely different tonal repertoire, rather than something that's just *slightly* different.

Graham.


11 Oct 05 - 11:59 AM (#1581027)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: Paco Rabanne

Do a 'Dylan' and 'borrow' a few to try first!


11 Oct 05 - 02:12 PM (#1581126)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: number 6

Good one flamenco ted ... very good indeed !!

sIx


11 Oct 05 - 04:09 PM (#1581231)
Subject: RE: A new guitar! Any suggestions?
From: GUEST,mandotim

I've just acquired a RainSong WS1100 carbon fibre guitar. If you want something different, give these a try. Second hand ones appear now and then at your price point. I paid $1300 for mine. Still made from trees, it's just that they are 30 million years old...great sound, clear, ringing tone and loads of volume. Fishman blender electrics too.
Tim from Bit on the Side