|
|||||||
Lyr Req: Make this a "Folk song" (Rusty Bells) |
Share Thread
|
Subject: I Wanna Make this a From: Benson Date: 24 Dec 98 - 05:20 PM Can I do this???? Can I make this a "folk song"??? It was such a lovely tune done by Brenda Lee......and it sure defies the "pop categories"...... Rusty Bells Brenda Lee (Richard Albert ..Eddie Snyder)
No one praying in the chapel |
Subject: RE: I Wanna Make this a From: dick greenhaus Date: 24 Dec 98 - 09:58 PM Just get a horse to refuse to sing it. |
Subject: RE: I Wanna Make this a From: Barbara Shaw Date: 27 Dec 98 - 07:10 PM The lyrics sound like they might make a good bluegrass song. Just use the right instrumentation (guitar, banjo, mandolin, bass, fiddle, maybe Dobro) and some harmony and it's bluegrass! (Some would call that a branch of Folk, some would call Folk a branch of bluegrass. . .) |
Subject: RE: I Wanna Make this a From: dick greenhaus Date: 28 Dec 98 - 01:02 PM Barbara- Folk came first. And grass doesn't have branches. |
Subject: RE: I Wanna Make this a From: Benson Date: 28 Dec 98 - 02:24 PM Dear Dick, Were it not that I perceive your post as being "Tongue in cheek".....I would, perhaps, take exception.... I would indeed suggest that although the grass may not have branches....."bluegrass" has branches beyoond most peoples comprehension......And, may I add, what is lacking in "branches".....it makes up for in fervent "roots". As I will concede that "Folk" came first.......Much of what many perceive as "folk" came considerably later......But I would consider "Bluegrass" as being a purist form only contained within regional boundaies......And certain time constraints...... To the absolute purist...I am quite sure it would be a matter of issue.......In which case, I would wonder whether or not it was proper to play folk songs on......Say a Martin Guitar.....?????? Awwww forgive my "idle ramblings"...I was just thinking out loud......"my mind tends to wander...it just never seems to get very far"...!!!
|
Subject: RE: I Wanna Make this a From: Zorro Date: 28 Dec 98 - 09:13 PM Who really cares which came first the chicken or the egg? I suppose a folklorist might ponder the question of the relationship of bluegrass and folk, but me I just enjoy playing and listening to both, the latter better than the former... Cheers and happy holly-days! Z |
Subject: RE: I Wanna Make this a From: hank Date: 29 Dec 98 - 09:42 AM Sigh, I had it all arranged. I could hear the mandolin on the rusty bells, the banjo/guitar on the verse... Then Barbra goes and reminds me that you could be a purist and not call bluegrass folk. I wonder if adding a harp with the mandolin on the rusty bells would get it out of bluegrass... Anyway, it is a great idea, but I think it needs work. Drop some words, add others. So here is how I see it. Think of John Denver's Country Roads for the start of the tune. However this is a different song and different sound. You can make that out yourself. Almost empty, all the chapels Rusty bells.....Rusty bells....(this is a moarnful sound the first time, and brigher the rest, don't be afraid to sing flat) Pity those who've gone astray When we are, scared and beaten (bridge)I heard them ring in the morning in the evening (last courus)Make it mine, make me free Copyright 1998, Henry Miller and the Digital Tardition. I'm glad my boss is on vacation today. I hope this what you were looking for, cause I've spent a lot mroe time then I should on it. I'm sure when you try to arrange it yourself that something will have to change again. |
Subject: RE: I Wanna Make this a From: Earl Date: 29 Dec 98 - 10:42 AM I stopped going to bluegrass festivals after seeing Tony Triska and Bela Fleck doing a banjo duet of a Bach song from sheet music. Some branches of bluegrass need pruning. |
Subject: RE: I Wanna Make this a From: Bert Date: 29 Dec 98 - 10:58 AM Benson, Just keep singing it. That's all we can do. It's our duty as folk singers to sing the songs that we like. Those that get remembered will eventually become 'folk' for future generations. If no one sings it, it will get lost. Bert.
|
Subject: RE: I Wanna Make this a From: Bert Date: 29 Dec 98 - 11:29 AM Benson, Just keep singing it. That's all we can do. It's our duty as folk singers to sing the songs that we like. Those that get remembered will eventually become 'folk' for future generations. If no one sings it, it will get lost. Bert.
|
Subject: RE: I Wanna Make this a From: Bill Cameron Date: 29 Dec 98 - 12:51 PM Even if a horse refuses to sing it, I don't think it can be a folk song unless you can arrange for someone to get stabbed multiple times, preferably by their erstwhile significant other. If not a murder, a fatal accident in the vicinity of the chapel will suffice. Plus the song starts out on a properly plaintive melancholy note but ends with unseemly optimism. That don't happen in bluegrass. Bill
|
Subject: RE: I Wanna Make this a From: Barbara Shaw Date: 29 Dec 98 - 12:58 PM Close call. I'm so tempted to get into the "categories" discussion (for the bohillionth time). I'm fighting it. . . |
Subject: RE: I Wanna Make this a From: Anne Date: 30 Dec 98 - 11:12 PM Benson, Of Course you can make it a folk song. Greg Brown has been known to sing "Fever." Peggy Lee woulda been proud. Anne |
Subject: RE: I Wanna Make this a From: Frank McGrath Date: 31 Dec 98 - 09:04 PM Dear Benson, To make this an Irish folk song just;
Come all ye loyal church goers Oh oil your bells and oil yourselves You may not get into the folk record charts but I'll warrant you'll earn a few free pints on the house. Happy New Year Frank McGrath |
Subject: RE: I Wanna Make this a From: misty Date: 31 Dec 98 - 09:36 PM happy new year!!!!! |
Subject: RE: I Wanna Make this a From: Craig Date: 02 Jan 99 - 02:08 AM I'll drink to that. |
Subject: RE: I Wanna Make this a From: BSeed Date: 02 Jan 99 - 02:26 AM Frank, much as I love spirituals, I'm wild about spirits-uals. --seed |
Subject: RE: I Wanna Make this a From: Banjeray Date: 02 Jan 99 - 07:36 AM To make it a true Irish folk song I think that at least two or three Guiness Stouts or other dark Ales must be consumed prior to writing OR playing. |
Share Thread: |
Subject: | Help |
From: | |
Preview Automatic Linebreaks Make a link ("blue clicky") |