You really are pushing this - third site that its up on. Interestingly - why do you use a different name on this one than the other two.   Thinking about it I use a different name on this one to the other two because I joined this one first. Nevermind. mind wandering as I have had a couple of glasses of wine and watched Shrek 2 , perfect Saturday night in.

I've had look at the site and it is quite interesting and I've also noted the debate on other sites. A few years ago the Scots-Irish section of one of the universities was very keen involved in Sheffield Irish festival and I believe they gave a lecture. I didn't go due to pressure of work.

I'ld pass the link onto a fiddler friend of mine who has spent time in Belfast and see what he thinks.

As a Scot involved in the Irish Community it is quite interesting

J