I am really surprised at how much score-settling this thread has generated (and the previous, now locked, one). It reminds me, a little bit, of how much hysteria there was after the death of Diana Spencer in 1997 and how difficult it was for some to voice a view contrary to the prevailing social mood. No comparison here, of course, just an example.

In relation to old hippie's suggestion that she should sing "All the traditional songs from her region that she has probably singing around the house for years; that would make a great 2 or 3 CD set", I can only ask: why do you think she knows any, or would even be interested in singing them? Because someone comes from a non-urban background doesn't mean that they're immersed in the culture of the region.

In a current mag feature on Scots singer Eddi Reader (now renowned for her wonderful interpretations of the songs of Robert Burns) she notes that she was brought up in a working-class city community, the only music in the house was that of the radio, trad music did not figure at all, or make any impact on her style or taste. She developed her interests and skills in later years. Just being Scots didn't make her know her cultural roots, or even be interested in them.

Maybe it's the same for Ms Boyle? Are we starting to turn her into something / someone we want her to be rather than what she is, and wants to be herself? Is this any different from commenting on her appearance?

Flame away!