Nerd,

I would say yes, some of us would judge the character of a person who has done what Nic Jones has done with this CD, and that it is not unreasonable to do so.

I am aware of the history of Nic's unfortunate accident and his subsequent troubles with Celtic Music. None of that excuses the cover art, IMO. Rather, it reveals something about the man I was shocked to discover, particularly in light of his disability.

You seem to be saying I have no right to judge someone I don't know personally. If this were not a public figure, I would agree. However, Nic Jones is a well known and highly regarded figure in the English folk scene. In that regard, I do have a right to judge his actions--particularly an action so blatant and, in my view, offensive.

I had always enjoyed Nic's music. However, my opinion of him as an artist and a man plummeted when I saw the cover art. I realize others will have different opinions, and that they are as free to express theirs as I am mine.

As I said earlier, I stand by my criticism of the artist and the man for his choice of cover art. Truth, like beauty and humor, is in the eye of the beholder. I have spoken the truth as I see it. The cover art on this CD was bound to be commented upon because of it's shocking nature. Are we not to express our opinions on it, unless they are either positive or supportive of Nic Jones?