 sj |
||
|
||
Modern Blues Players, your thoughts.
|
|
|
Subject: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Steve Latimer Date: 26 Feb 01 - 11:40 AM I have been a blues fan for many of my 41 years. I was introduced to the genre by the sixties/seventies Blues Rock bands. I have always been a fan of the guitar, especially blues guitar. Tone & feel are my foremost requirements when listening to blues. Here are my thoughts on the "Modern" (post delta) blues players I've heard. Muddy Waters: "Muddy Waters invented electricity". Perhaps an overstatement, but when he plugged in it changed the course of music. There have been people more technically proficient than Muddy, but what feel and what a songwriter. Johnny Winter: Johnny is my favourite modern guy. He has incredible feel, tone and in his day was lightning fast. I know people who found him excessive, but I never did. He's the finest slide player I've ever heard, especially electric slide. He got a little out of sorts in the seventies when the record company tried to push him in the rock direction. He turned his back on this and re-focused on the blues. He not only recorded some great solo stuff, but his work with Muddy Waters and Sonny Terry was wonderful. Stevie Ray Vaughan: I somtimes have a hard time with SRV. I found that a lot of the time he was trying to sound like either Albert King or Jimi Hendrix. I also got sick of hearing "Stevie is God" and the huge number of Stevie Ray Vaughanabee bands playing his stuff note for note. However, he was a great player with killer tone and feel. Jimi Hendrix: I think that Jimi is often overlooked as a bluesman. Most of his better known material was more Psychedelic Rock, but when he played the blues it was the real deal. I really loved the direction he was taking with Buddy Miles and Billy Cox when he died. He seemed to be returning to his Blues and R&B roots. Rory Gallagher: Rory was another very fine player, good slide player. He wasn't afraid to take chances. Jimmy Page: I used to love Zeppelin and Page when I was a teenager. I have a hard time listening to a lot of his stuff now. I found him to be a very flashy and showy player. B.B. King: I used to really like B.B., but I find that he is extremely repetitive and boring. I had gone off of him completely until I heard some of his stuff from the fifties that was really good. Albert King: Great, great sound. SRV's hero. Eric Clapton: This is the one that I have the most trouble with. I loved Eric's early blues, almost gagged at his Pop star stuff and had completely gone off him, He then released "From the Cradle" and was once more a fine blues player. I loved his version of "Don't Think Twice" at Bobfest". I just wish he would figure out who he is. Frank Zappa: Better known for his satire than his playing, but I think he was a musical genius. When Frank just got down and jammed the blues it was incredible. Bob Dylan: What the hell is he doing on this list??? Listen to the first Dylan CD. A great bluesman. Jeff Beck: I have never heard anyone play the electric guatar like Jeff. He is inventive, tremendously musical, but I thought his attempts at blues were weak. Taj Mahal: I think this man is one of the most musical people I've ever heard. Taj is deeply rooted in the music of the thirties and forties, but he has done some incredible modern electric blues is career. That's all I can think of for now. Anyone else?
|
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: wysiwyg Date: 26 Feb 01 - 11:55 AM ...... oh crap, CRS.... Dharmabum sent me a tape..... a whole fresh blues thing happening.... a young feller.... the name... DANG!! Dang CRS! Was it Eric Bibb? That guy. And all the women you left off the list! *G* ~S~ |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Dharmabum Date: 26 Feb 01 - 12:10 PM Yup Susan,it was Eric Bibb. He's the son of the 60s folk singer Leon Bibb. Steve,As far as electric biues,I agree with most of your list,but I think I'd add Elmore James to it> . Ron |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: wysiwyg Date: 26 Feb 01 - 12:29 PM Thanks DB RonBro. Bonnie Raitt!!! Sippie Wallace I guess would be her bluesmother. (Like a godmother.) (But ya got to know how!) ~S~ |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Steve Latimer Date: 26 Feb 01 - 12:37 PM You're right, I forgot women. I have only heard a bit of Joanne Kelly, but what I heard was great.
|
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Lonesome EJ Date: 26 Feb 01 - 12:57 PM Janis Joplin- She was a true blues soul-singer in the mode of Bessie Smith, and gave women legitimacy as the central focus of a blues band.
Freddie King- Guitarist/singer with a great feel for Chicago-style electric blues overlaid with rock sensibilities. Peter Green- The former Fleetwood Mac singer and guitarist had some of the most fluid blues runs, coupled with biting hooks. Paul Butterfield- What a blues harp man! What a group with Elvin Bishop and Mike Bloomfield! They brought true Chicago-style to the rock listener without compromising their art. John Mayall- The entire Blues Revival owes much to John, whose tight blues combos featured future guitar heroes like Pete Green, Eric Clapton and Jimmy Page. Robert Cray- Smooth and mellow bluesman who owes a big debt to BB. Johnny Lang- So what if he got his start on the Disney Channel? He's got a great vocal and guitar style. Susan Tedeschi- Some of Janis, some of Bonnie, a little Stevie Ray. Hope for the future.
|
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Justa Picker Date: 26 Feb 01 - 01:06 PM Lest we forget.... Steve Cropper Roy Buchanan Rick Derringer Mick Taylor Keb Mo
|
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Justa Picker Date: 26 Feb 01 - 01:07 PM oh and Rory Block |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Steve Latimer Date: 26 Feb 01 - 01:14 PM I meant to mention Roy Buchanan in my original post. Wonderful player. Keb Mo is a guy I'm just warming to now. Robert Cray is a guy I find to be way to homogenized, lots of technique, not a lot of feel. Kind of the anti-John Lee Hooker, who has very little technique, tons of feel. |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: GUEST Date: 26 Feb 01 - 01:33 PM Warren Haynes - picked up where Clapton left off with Cream ... a wicked slide master as well, but slide doesn't do for me what it does for a lot of folks. Haynes leans more towards blues-based rock, but his band Gov't Mule is hard to beat when they cut loose on blues standards like "Mother Earth." Haynes does lots of collaborations with other blues artists like Little Milton and Kenny Wayne Shepherd, and some not so steeped in the blues tradition, like Everlast. Billy Gibbons - ZZTop. That down 'n' dirty Texas roadhouse sound. Susan Tedeschi - soulful in the Bonnie Rait tradition. Shannon Curfman - just fourteen when her first album Loud Guitars Big Suspicions came out (1999), her guitar work makes someone who's been at it a while just want to give up in disgust. She's not real flashy, but it's evident she knows her way around a fretboard. Seth Yacovone Band - Seth Yacovone hails from Vermont, opens for the likes of BB King, Johnny Winter et al. A complete track from Dannemora is downloadable for free at the band's website: www.sethyac.com. Guitar Shorty - he's best known for being married to Hendrix's stepsister, and when he does a version of "Hey Joe" you get a good idea from whom Jimi learned a few of his licks. Matt 'Guitar' Murphy - I like the work he did with Memphis Slim. |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: RWilhelm Date: 26 Feb 01 - 05:47 PM I like Little Charlie Baty and Rick Estrin of Little Charlie and the Nightcats Buddy Guy Katie Webster John Mooney Marcia Ball For comtemporary accustic blues I like: Corey Harris Guy Davis |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Gray Rooster Date: 26 Feb 01 - 06:32 PM All of the above plus - Lonesome Dave (early Savoy Brown) played the finest blues backup I can recall while Kim Simmonds blistered the blues on top. 'Sides - ain't it all blues, anyhoo? *BG* |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Stewie Date: 26 Feb 01 - 06:58 PM I like many of the above. Some of my favourites that have not been mentioned:
Koerner, Ray and Glover |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: bigchuck Date: 26 Feb 01 - 07:04 PM How about Steve James, Kelly Joe Phelps, George Gritzbach? |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Mountain Dog Date: 26 Feb 01 - 08:41 PM A fine list, all. I'd have to add a few: The late, great J.B. Hutto (a howlin', slidewindin' protege of Elmore James), Koko Taylor, Hound Dog Taylor, Luther Allison and Guitar Jr. I did have the pleasure of seeing Muddy on his last tour; a moving experience in every sense of the phrase. Billy Gibbons' guitar work on ZZ Top's First Album stands the test of time for me; kinda think he went downhill from there.
|
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: ddw Date: 26 Feb 01 - 09:28 PM Guess I'm just the dinosaur here. I've heard the old saw about Muddy Waters inventing electricity, but my view is that he electrocuted the blues — sent the genre to the electric chair, as it were. With very few exceptions — James Cotton, Sonny Boy Williamson II, Willie Dixon and a few others — I just don't like the plugged-in bluesmen. For my money, none of them can touch the feeling and musical expertise of people like Josh White, Blind Blake, Blind Boy Fuller, Blind Lemon Jefferson, Rev. Gary Davis, Big Bill Broonzy, John Hurt, Leadbelly and a host of others who could mezmerize audiences without all the jumped-up techs and accompaniment the later guys relied on. There are a few still trying to carry their torches — Keb Mo, Josh White Jr., John Hammond and John Cephus and Phil Wiggins spring to mind — but it looks like people with my tastes are doomed to extinction. Sigh..... david |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: catspaw49 Date: 26 Feb 01 - 09:37 PM Oddly enough, I ran onto Keb Mo in a video which I rarely watch. After that I watched the damn things some more hoping to get some more, but there was no Mo. Of all the guys out there now as dw says, "carrying the torch," he strikes me as the real thing. What do I know though? I just like him. Spaw |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Bluesman and kde Date: 26 Feb 01 - 09:58 PM You folks have already mentioned most of my favorite guitar players and for the most part, I feel mostly the same about some that are fluid and some that are not. The first guitarists I listened to in the late '50's, early '60's were Scotty Moore (not the best by any means, but he did play with Elvis), James Burton (Ricky Nelson) who was one of the hottest players ever, and Lonnie Mack, who, when he came out with "Memphis", almost made me sell my guitar!!! LOL And Josh White Sr. was like a God to me. |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: ddw Date: 27 Feb 01 - 12:17 AM Bluesman — If you like JW Sr., have you ever listened to Lonnie Johnson? I'm not wild about his vocal style, but he was an extraordinary guitarist. He was going toward jazz before Josh was, but he didn't, in my estimation, have the same spareness. Josh always seemed to put exactly the right note in exactly the right place, but without making it seem like he was just a technician. BTW, don't know if you've picked up on it, but there's another M'cat regular who shares our enthusiasm for Josh. I've seen Rick Fielding post a couple of times that Josh is his FAVORITE guitarist. cheers, david |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Brian Hoskin Date: 27 Feb 01 - 04:29 AM Just to add a couple more players to this great list, two performers I was lucky enough to catch live last year: Corey Harris - great voice, great guitar and Mike Hill's Blues Mob - from New York I believe, haven't heard any recordings, but they sounded fantastic live. Brian |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: GUEST,Sooze(at work) Date: 27 Feb 01 - 05:32 AM Its Eric Bibb for me but also look out for Emily Druce - a young Yorkshire lass who is on the way up. Other thoughts - what about Woody Mann, Greg Wright, Ralph Mactell........ My other half Mike isn't so bad either! |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: GUEST,Roger the skiffler Date: 27 Feb 01 - 05:36 AM If we're sticking to modern there's R.L. Burnside (in the Fred McDowell tradition) and a few more women: Susan Tedeschi,Bonnie Raitt, Dana Gillespie. Jools Holland's guitarist, Mark ?Buchanan is pretty good as is Chris Barber's John Slaughter. Harp players include- Paul Jones. Pianists- Chuck Lavell. RtS |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: LR Mole Date: 27 Feb 01 - 10:05 AM Just saw Johnny Clegg (Jonny?) who looks about twelve but sounds fifty- five when he sings, and plays the everlasting snot out of a custom Telecaster.And let us not forget the elegant Geoffrey Muldaur. |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Jim the Bart Date: 27 Feb 01 - 10:10 AM Magic Slim. Gone, but hardly forgotten. |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: GUEST,Mike Billo Date: 27 Feb 01 - 11:02 AM How about Ry Cooder? For acoustic players, I nominate the duo of Tom Ball and Kenny Sultan. Among modern blues women, Del Rey is my favorite. |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: John Hardly Date: 27 Feb 01 - 02:57 PM I guess he's not mentioned yet because he's out of the 3-chord mainstream. Also most mentioned previous are 'lectric. The guy who captures the soul of it for me, who has me near tears one moment and laughing the next--Chris Smither. Especially "Another Way To Find You" |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Lonesome EJ Date: 27 Feb 01 - 03:23 PM This guy is great,if you like solid Delta Blues pickin and singin.Name is Scott Ainslie,and you can listen to audio clips here y'all.I especially like his Parchman's Farm and the Billie Holiday tune. Go to the bottom of the page and click audio samples. You can order cds from Scott by e-mailing him and sending a check. He'll autograph them for you. Scott is a Robert Johnson disciple, and wrote a biography of him. He also has a Johnson Instruction video, for those of you who want to play like Robert, but aren't interested in selling your soul. |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Murray MacLeod Date: 27 Feb 01 - 03:34 PM I am surprised nobody has mentioned Martin Simpson here. Probably because he is so phenomenally accomplished in so many other guitar styles, but IMNSHO he has no equal today as a blues slide player. Murray |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Steve Latimer Date: 27 Feb 01 - 03:46 PM ddw, Don't get me wrong. I love the originators, I very rarely find myself listening to the modern guys these days. But I found Robert Johnson, Son House, Blind Willie McTell, Blind Willie Johnson, Lightnin' Hopkins, Mississippi through having heard the modern guys. When I first heard Johnny Winter doing Broke Down Engine on a National steel I realized that I had to find out where that came from. It's been a long road and from the looks of this thread one that I will never finish exploring. This thread started because a colleague of my Girlfriend's heard that I loved the blues and loaned her a few CD's for me to listen to. It is primarily modern stuff and it just got me thinking about some of the guys I've listened to before. I think that both Pre-Muddy Waters electric and Post Muddy Waters electric are valid forms of the blues. |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Lonesome EJ Date: 27 Feb 01 - 03:53 PM Thanks for starting the thread Steve - good way to find out how many of us Blues Fans are knocking around on the Forum. |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Steve Latimer Date: 27 Feb 01 - 03:59 PM Lonesome EJ, You're welcome. It was also inspired by the thread last week about Blues links. In that one Max stated that he started Mudcat as a site dedicated to Blues & Folk music and that blues is his first love. Just listening to Taj Mahal doing Elizabeth Cotten's "Freight Train". Steve |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: ddw Date: 28 Feb 01 - 12:39 AM Steve I agree that there are post-Muddy players who are doing the blues. I mentioned a few of them. But so much of what is called blues these days — as evidenced by some of your choices in the first post on this thread — doesn't qualify in my view. Just like there is a dividing line between country and rock'n'roll, there is a cutoff between blues and the post-R'n'R rock that has its roots in blues. I definitely think there is a point of "innovation" around a style of playing and singing that makes it something else and it would take a helluva lot of convincing to get me to think Jimi Hendrix played blues. There was a magic in one man with one guitar being able to carry a whole dance or put an audience through an emotional wringer that just gets lost when you get a whole bunch of musicians playing together to do the same thing. Sure, some of these guys can play guitar and — if they would — sing. But screaming, either vocally or instrumentally, doesn't make me feel THEIR anger as much as it makes me feel mine at having to listen to it. To me blues is about emotion expressed through finesse, not primal scream. Maybe I'm just coming at this from a little different perspective. I used to listen to WLAC, a Nashville, TN station, back in the '50s when they sold "race records" to the black population of the southern U.S. They played Muddy Waters, Bobby "Blue" Bland, B.B. King, John Lee Hooker and lots of others who were recording in Chicago and New York at the time. I liked that music better than the country and early rocka'n'roll that were standard fare around where I lived, but in about 1958 somebody introduced me to Josh White, Leadbelly and Big Bill Broonzy and I realized that the guys I'd been listening to were not a patch on the old masters — and that was before I heard Blind Blake, Blind Boy Fuller, Willie McTell, John Hurt and Mance Lipscomb. In my estimation Hendrix and King couldn't carry most of the old guys' guitar cases. Oddly enough, most of the better blues players since the old masters have been white, middle-class boys. I just hope some of them are still alive when young black men rediscover the music so the techniques can be passed back to the people who started it all. But I guess we have to wait for rap to run its course and for young blacks to rediscover MUSIC as a way to convey their angst and joy. cheers, david |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Bluesman and kde Date: 28 Feb 01 - 07:22 AM I forgot to mention Ry Cooder in my previous posting. He has lots of CD's out, which I have all but a couple, but I think the best one is "Crossroads", which is from the movie of the same name. Another obscure bluesman is Terry Evans who did back-up vocals on several Ry Cooder CD's. Cooder has finally produced a couple of albums for Terry and he is one of the most soulful singers I've ever heard. He plays acoustic guitar on them with Ry playing that awesome slide that he plays. Know most of you will love his work. Recently deceased Pop Staples is another favorite of mine. Ry plays on several cuts on the two CD's I have of him. Another bit of info is that all 3 have recorded "Down in Mississippi" and though Ry plays on all 3 versions, they are so different, but all 3 versions are great. Give them a listen...........Jim
|
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: GUEST Date: 28 Feb 01 - 09:09 AM There's a distinction between rock musicians who acknowledge their blues influences occasionally, and those musicians who strictly play blues, however one cares to define the genre. Regardless, just because Leadbelly sang "Bluetail Fly" doesn't diminish his stature as a bluesman, no more than Hendrix singing "Purple Haze" diminishes his stellar reindition of "Red House." One listen to Hendrix's version of that song should be enough to convince anyone that he knew blues inside out and upside down (literally). Perhaps the high decibel trend of those early so-called "psychedelic" times stems less from the desire to do sonic damage and more from the fact that those '60's Marshall heads had to be cranked to get the siren-esque tone of mournful urgency those guys loved so much. And while Leadbelly's "field hollers" are somewhat more subdued than an out-and-out primal scream, they both serve to reflect the same feeling of frustration born of despair. Even Clapton describes himself, when all is said and done, as a blues guitarist, notwithstanding his success with the 'unplugged' ballads. And he, of all people, should be the foremost authority on his playing. Those rare occasions when he is caught on video noodling around on his Strat seem to confirm this. It's those same five notes of the pentatonic scale, done to death but never losing their ability to evoke the feelings we associate with the blues. |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Steve Latimer Date: 28 Feb 01 - 11:29 AM Guest, You beat me to it and said it more eloquently than I could have. Jimi's acoustic "Hear My Train A Comin'" could easily slipped onto a compilation CD of Bukka, RJ, MJH, Son House etc and would fit right in. |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: GUEST Date: 28 Feb 01 - 12:47 PM Spot on, Steve Latimer. |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: black walnut Date: 28 Feb 01 - 01:39 PM They've been already mentioned: Kelly Joe Phelps Martin Simpson ~b.w.
|
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: ddw Date: 01 Mar 01 - 12:21 AM OK, Steve and GUEST, I'm willing to be convinced. I've never even heard of Hendrix playing acoustic, but I'm certainly going to look up some of it. I've never heard him do anything be what I consider flat-out rock and The Star Spangled Banner. Guest, am I missing your point about Leadbelly, or are you agreeing with me that he was able to get at the emotion without resorting to primal scream? I've got no problem with rough, raucous voices SINGING, but I lose interest when it goes into the scream range. Any four-year-old can have a tantrum and be about as musical as some of the modern purveyors of what's passing for blues these days. david |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: GUEST Date: 01 Mar 01 - 08:07 AM ddw... Essentially I am in agreement with you about Leadbelly being able to get at the emotion without resorting to voice box suicide. I was merely pointing out my belief that there are some similarities between Leadbelly's "field hollers" and the primal screams of Janis Joplin, for example. I realize this is arguable. It boils down to the old saw about "diff'rent strokes...." Accoustic Hendrix is somewhat rare. Obviously he wasn't known for being unplugged. The track Latimer refers to shows up on a posthumous compilation of blues imaginatively titled, "Blues,", and is the only accoustic track on the recording, if memory serves. |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Steve Latimer Date: 01 Mar 01 - 09:48 AM ddw, Ah, "The Star Spangled Banner" maybe the most excessive of Jimi's Live performance excesses. Unfortunately for many people this is one of the few tracks that they've heard by Jimi and it is easy to discount him based on this. Hear My Train A Comin' is one of only a few acoustic tunes I've ever heard Jimi do. I first heard it years ago, it was on the soundtrack of "A Film About Jimi Hendrix". It was a rare moment indeed and has since been re-released on the CD "Blues" that Guest refers to. Given the dates that you mention I am guessing that you are at least 15 years older than me (I'll be 42 this month). Your musical tastes were formed before Jimi changed the way the guitar was played, mine after. I can see how he might have been hard to take for a purist. For me, he was one of the people who made me realize that I loved the Blues and had to find out more about it, yet I sure liked a lot of what he gave us. And let there be no bones about, a lot of the stuff, especially live performances that were released after his death was crap. Jimi had his demons. Music is nothing more than sounds and lyrics. A lot of the electric blues sounds were essentially the same as those that the guys from the twenties and thirties were striving for with the slide, the modern guys did with volume and sustain. Despair and angst. I've often wondered what sounds Robert Johnson would have created had the Stratocaster and a Marshall stack been around in his day.
|
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: ddw Date: 01 Mar 01 - 10:51 PM GUEST, I guess we'll just have to leave it at "it's arguable" on the holler/scream question, but I still have to come down saying Leadbelly's hollers were a lot closer to music than JJ's screaming — a pretty good imitation of which you can get by poking a pig in the ass with a hatpin. I still also have some trouble with categorizing JH as a "blues" guitarist based on a few cuts. It might prove he COULD HAVE BEEN a bluesman, but his body of work still says to me he wasn't. Steve, You're spot on on the age difference — I'm a few months short of 58. And you're right about my taste forming before Hendrix changed the way guitar was played. I was in university when Hendrix was big (I'd spent six years between high school and Univ.) and a lot of my friends thought he was wonderful. I didn't agree then and I don't agree now. I'm not even sure I can concede that the electric guitar is any more a guitar than an organ is a piano — I consider them different instruments. I also have some trouble relating to the argument that volume and sustain convey the same emotional range as subtlely played, well-placed notes. They might both be able to make you happy or sad or angry, but to me there is a QUALITATIVE difference in the feelings the two can evoke. Maybe I'm a fossile and don't understand the "language" of the electric guitar, but I find its emotional range limited more to angry, angrier and ready to kill something. But then, I like Beethoven and hate Bartok and I won't allow an artificial Christmas tree in the house. David — dug in and flak jacket on..... |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: GUEST Date: 02 Mar 01 - 12:55 PM ddw..."I still also have some trouble with categorizing JH as a "blues" guitarist based on a few cuts. It might prove he COULD HAVE BEEN a bluesman, but his body of work still says to me he wasn't." Exactly. "There's a distinction between rock musicians who acknowledge their blues influences occasionally, and those musicians who strictly play blues, however one cares to define the genre." Hendrix obviously falls in the former category. He wasn't a bluesman, he was a psychedelic hard rockin' electric guitar player...he knew which side his bread was buttered on. Maybe he'd heard too many stories about Robert Johnson et al dying penniless and unknown. But he knew blues and could play electric blues with the best of 'em. (all caveat emptors from a Hendrix fan apply) |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Lonesome EJ Date: 02 Mar 01 - 02:35 PM Those familiar with Hendrix's Star Spangled Banner should listen to the track that follows it on the Woodstock soundtrack album...a very moody, near-acoustic rendering that features the beautiful runs and fills that Hendrix was so adept at, and which often put his music in the category of Jazz more accurately than in the rock or blues area. I believe that Hendrix's playing had an impact on how guitar is played in nearly every genre, including rock,country,jazz and blues. Whether you like the change he wrought or not is another question. |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Justa Picker Date: 02 Mar 01 - 03:09 PM I've always thought of Jimi as being all about blues, and thoroughly grounded in it. He just took it to a whole new level, and thousands of electric players world wide do, and have done, everything they can to emulate his style. He plays electric blues with more emotion (with the arguable exception of maybe Roy Buchanan) than anyone I've ever heard before or since. He was truly one of a kind. |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Peter T. Date: 02 Mar 01 - 04:04 PM I think Janis Joplin is in a Mount Everest category of her own, all by herself: JANIS JOPLIN. yours, Peter T. |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Steve Latimer Date: 02 Mar 01 - 04:13 PM Lonesome EJ, The piece that you refer to is one of my favourite Hendrix pieces. Too bad it was so short. Steve |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: Rich(bodhránai gan ciall) Date: 03 Mar 01 - 12:18 AM John Cephas and Phil Wiggins, absolutely floored me when I saw them. I really don't know the genre well, but I have some friends here in Pittsburgh that recommend stuff and I almost invariably like what I hear. Pat Donahue, The self-proclaimed "Two Hand Band" is entirely too modest. He's makes that guitar sound like an orchestra. Paul Rishell and Annie Raines, I've seen them twice as a duet as well as with John Sebastian's "J-Band" Paul does some nice work with a Strat, but he really shines on a National Steel guitar. Annie makes her harmonica talk. As a pair they're incredible! And one I'll probably get an argument about: Carole King, She's classified as a singer-songwriter and certainly that title applies, but I've caught myself listening to a couple songs off of "Tapestry" and thing they could easily fit into either an electric or country blues format. Particularly "Way Over Yonder". And she sings with more soul than one normally would expect from a "Pop Artist of the Year" Just my $.02 Rich |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: iceboy Date: 12 Feb 02 - 08:10 PM David; Don't know what you're listening to when bashing Muddy, but some of the newer traditional players you site couldn't hold a candle to either Muddy or the outstanding pre-war masters you site. I'll let you figure out which ones I'm referring to. At least one is little more than a thinly veiled pop artist meticulously cultivating a classic bluesman image. If you don't hear the soul and mastery in Louisiana Blues and Muddy's version of Kindhearted Woman, while simultaneously touting some of the newer artists who are just beginning to scratch the surface of the work the pre-war masters created, then I think you need to seriously go back and take another listen to all of it. Lotsa luck, Iceboy |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: ddw Date: 12 Feb 02 - 08:59 PM Iceboy, I haven't heard any of Josh Jr's stuff recently, so I can't judge on anything later than about 10 years, but his earlier stuff was following pretty well in Dad's footsteps. I'm disappointed with Keb Mo's latest album and suspect you might be referring to the direction he's headed in. As for Muddy's stuff... I've heard it and —— sorry —— I'm just not that impressed. I like him a lot better than B.B. King and a lot of JL Hooker's work, but he doesn't speak to me the way Sonny Boy Williamson II (Rice Miller) or Willie Dixon or James Cotton does. Maybe we're just listening for different things and there's nothing we can do about that, but I've said before and I'll say again that the plugged-in players who treat the guitar like a trumpet just don't do the same thing for me as the one-man, one-guitar masters who could carry a whole dance or keep an audience in thrall with little or no backup. Somebody came up with a great quote in a recent thread. It was something to the effect that one of the old bluesmen (can't recall which, but it might have been Blind Blake had 16 licks. Another venerated player learned eight of them and passed four on the next, who passed two to other bluesmen. Now most "blues" players learn one lick and think they're accomplished bluesmen. I'll try to find that quote and pass it along when I have time, but right now I have to get back to work. cheers, david |
|
Subject: RE: Modern Blues Players, your thoughts. From: iceboy Date: 12 Feb 02 - 09:09 PM I realize this thread lived and died many months ago but I'll throw my two cents worth anyway. I just found this web-site. It's pretty clear from the names being referenced on this thread that MOST of the posters relay on rockers for their blues exposure. Jimi Hendrix was a brilliant R&B, soul, and rock guitarist in a similar vein to Curtis Mayfield, Cornell Dupree, and Don Covay. He was masterful and imaginative, but not a bluesman, although he did borrow heavily from John Lee Hooker and Lightnin' Hopkins, among others. Eric Clapton, Jeff Beck, Jimmy Page, Roy Buchanan, and Johnny Winter (Johnny and his brother put out some amazing R&B vocal demos in the early 60's) are rockers who cover blues songs, but not with a valid blues sensibility or dynamic range. Eric Clapton WISHES he could sound like B.B., Freddie, and Otis Rush sounded in the fifties. Buddy Guy proved in the early sixties that electric blues guitar could have a dynamic range from a whisper to a scream. Earl Hooker was a master of phrasing and time. If you want to compare pre-war to post-war blues, that's fair enough. Let's just make sure we're talking about blues masters, not pop mimics. Iceboy |
| Share Thread: |