I think one of the problems is that compared with fans of other so-called music genre - by that I am referring to those for whom contestants on the latest pop talent show are the be all and end all of everything that matters in the world - us folkies are very politically and socially aware, and hold strong views according to our own perspectives. However, I do find it hard to understand how those who are drawn to folk music can be anything else but socialist - but that would be another thread.

In a way, it is a pity that the thread in question was closed as, but for the thread drift, it was asking some important questions.

I do see that threads do drift, and run into the danger of a one-to-one personalised exchange. I personally do not have problems between the banter between regular contributors, as long as it does not descend to personal abuse.

We should be self-moderating - perhaps a few techniques.

(1) Responses to comments criticising policy - can either agree or disagree, if disagree make a clear statement of why. Just stating that the other side were just as bad in the past does not contribute towards moving the debate forward.
(2) Be open where we are coming from, and accept that those who are equally open have the right to their views.
(3) Be encouraging to contibutions to debate from those other than the main protagonists, and respond without belittling. By all means, point out fallacies, but in a civil manner.
(4) If discussion is going off in a narrow tangent, bring the OP point back into the discussion, maybe with another avenue for discussion.
(5) For extended one-to-one 'battles', consider whether these contribute something of interest to other readers, or whether this should be a one-to-one exchange of personal messages.
(6)Avoid trying to out-intectualise other contibutors, it may feel good to score points, but it could very easily bore other readers. If cross referring, consider explaining what you are cross referring to.
(7) Avoid offensiveness in posts - not just towards Mudcat members, but to people in society. Criticise for what one does (and cite evidence) as oppose who one is, to avoid being mirrored.
(8) When cooments do get offenseive, be prpared to say 'whatever', and move the discussion to something more interesting.