Subject: Origins: From which song do these lines come? From: GUEST,Paul Hazell Date: 22 Aug 22 - 02:28 PM Can anyone here help please? A friend has quoted me the following lines and is very keen to ascertain from which song they are taken: "You Yankees and you Rebels shake hands and then forget, You'll never build a nation in all this bloody mess, Go home and read your bible and the Gettysburg address". Grateful for any help - thanks |
Subject: ADD: The Giant of the Thunderhead (Driftwood) From: cnd Date: 22 Aug 22 - 07:24 PM That is "The Giant and the Thunderhead" by Jimmy Driftwood. Here's my transcription. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AzOlh-MAQPo THE GIANT OF THE THUNDERHEAD (Jimmie Driftwood) A bunch of Rebel soldiers were sittin' 'round one night A-talkin' to some Yankees in a spot way out of sight They'd stepped across the picket line to have a little chat A chawin' their tobaccer and swappin' this and that And while they were a-talkin' they looked a-way up high And there they saw a man a-walkin' across the moonless sky He sat down on a pillow upon a thunderhead He looked down on the soldiers and this is what He said: CHORUS You Yankees and you Rebels, shake hands and then caress Go home and read your Bible and the Gettysburg Address The boys ran to their bed rolls afraid to talk out loud About the mighty giant they'd saw upon the cloud Next day two famous general met near an apple tree And one of them was U.S. Grant and one was Robert Lee And when they'd finished talking and everybody knew The awful war was over, they shouted Hallelu' And all the people wondered about the thunderhead Did U.S. Grant and Robert Lee hear what the giant said? CHORUS You'll never build a nation in all this bloody mess Go home and read your Bible and the Gettysburg Address You've got the grandest country this world has ever known Your Constitution is the brightest star that's ever shone CHORUS Go home and read your Bible and the Gettysburg Address |
Subject: RE: Origins: From which song do these lines come? From: cnd Date: 23 Aug 22 - 08:09 AM Oops, just realized I put "thunderbird" in one place -- it should all be thunderhead. |
Subject: RE: Origins: From which song do these lines come? From: cnd Date: 23 Aug 22 - 08:26 AM As it turns out, I was careless in a few places. First, the recording I based my transcription on is this one, not the one I linked above. Pretty obvious/minor mistake, but in the first stanza, it should be "A chawin' their tobaccer and swappin' this and that" |
Subject: RE: Origins: From which song do these lines come? From: Lighter Date: 23 Aug 22 - 10:26 AM "Caress"?! Ewwww! Even with the imperfect rhyme, "forget" is much better. |
Subject: RE: From which song do these lines come?-Thunderhead From: cnd Date: 23 Aug 22 - 02:00 PM Yeah, I have to assume they really liked the Gettysburg Address line and just forced something to make it work. Perhaps it could be "Go home and fix this mess"? |
Subject: RE: From which song do these lines come?-Thunderhead From: Mrrzy Date: 27 Aug 22 - 04:04 PM I kinda liked caress... |
Share Thread: |
Subject: | Help |
From: | |
Preview Automatic Linebreaks Make a link ("blue clicky") |