|
Subject: Folklore: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Peace Date: 19 Oct 09 - 08:03 PM I was reading a bang-bang shootem up entitled "traitor's kiss" by Gerald Seymour. At the beginning of each of twenty chapters he asks a question, the answer to which is Kaliningrad. This is the question for chapter 5. "Q. What is the birthplace of Max Coplet, the Jewish composer who wrote 'Where Have All The Flowers Gone' for Marlene Deitrich? A. Kaliningrad." Does anyone have the history of this song? |
|
Subject: RE: Folklore: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Peace Date: 19 Oct 09 - 08:05 PM PS The city used to be called Königsberg. |
|
Subject: RE: Folklore: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Q (Frank Staplin) Date: 19 Oct 09 - 08:23 PM Allmusic has over 300 citations for this song, nearly all of them listing Pete Seeger. The few other listings all seem to be arrangers. No 'Coplet' listed. However, this website gives information on Max Coplet and Marlene Dietrich. It says Dietrich was the first performer in 1962. The Kingston Trio is also mentioned. Later on, it says Seeger wrote it with three verses in 1960 and recorded it as part of a medley in 1960 on a "Rainbow Quest" album. Max Coplet wrote the German version for Dietrich (six verses). English, French and German lyrics given at this website: http://worldmusic.suite101.com/article.cfm/where_have_all_the_flowers_gone News to me! |
|
Subject: RE: Folklore: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Peace Date: 19 Oct 09 - 08:25 PM Thanks, Q. Was a shock to me because I'd thought it was written by Seeger. Sonuvagun. |
|
Subject: RE: Folklore: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Q (Frank Staplin) Date: 19 Oct 09 - 08:35 PM He did write the first part of it and Coplet expanded it, if I read the article correctly. I tried to print the German version, but it came up blank. The 'save' does work, however. |
|
Subject: RE: Folklore: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Mark Ross Date: 19 Oct 09 - 08:37 PM The song was written by Pete from a reference in Mikhail Sholokov's AND QUIET FLOWS THE DON. Therein is quoted an old Cossack folksong which later became the song we all know. Pete only wrote 3 verses, the others were added by Joe Hickerson. Max Coplet wrote the German translation. Mark Ross |
|
Subject: RE: Folklore: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Peace Date: 19 Oct 09 - 08:38 PM From the site you gave the address for, Q: "In the 50s, American folk singer Pete Seeger (1919 - ) often sang at college concerts. In 1958, en route to one of these concerts, on the plane, he had his inspiration for "Where Have All the Flowers Gone?". Seeger pulled out his pocket-size song notebook and as he recalls, "Leafing through it, I came across three lines I'd written down, oh, at least a year or two before". Seeger had read a novel by Mikhail Sholokhov, And Quiet Flows the Don, where he noted the three lines came from a Ukrainian folk song." Just when the world was seeming to be simple . . . . |
|
Subject: RE: Folklore: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Peace Date: 19 Oct 09 - 08:39 PM Thanks, Mark. Sorry to have cross-posted. |
|
Subject: RE: Folklore: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: GUEST,Young Buchan Date: 19 Oct 09 - 09:04 PM My favourite story about this song is that Gary Shearston, before he went on to become a pop singer, was asked to sing it on Australian TV. Just as he was about to start he was passed a note to say they were overrunning so could he leave out a couple of verses! |
|
Subject: RE: Folklore: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Don Firth Date: 19 Oct 09 - 09:08 PM I occasionally watch the Classic Arts Showcase channel. They play clips (videos, old films) from various performances, such as a scene from an opera, a song or two from a recital, a selection from a ballet, perhaps an excerpt from a classic film, or a selection from someone's night club act. One of the clips they show from time to time is Marlene Dietrich singing "Where Have All the Flowers Gone." She introduces it by crediting it to Pete Seeger. Out of her own mouth. Don Firth P. S. She sings it like she needs a vitamin shot, but that's another matter. . . . |
|
Subject: RE: Folklore: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Art Thieme Date: 19 Oct 09 - 09:52 PM JOE HICKERSON is the one who did most of this song. I can't believe nobody has given Joe the credit he deserves. Art |
|
Subject: RE: Folklore: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Susanne (skw) Date: 20 Oct 09 - 06:05 PM In Pete Seeger's own words: [1998:] In October, 1955, I was on a plane bound for Ohio - half dozing. I found in my pocket three lines copied a year before when I was reading, And Quiet Flows the Don, the Soviet novel by Mikhail Sholokhov, who describes the Cossack soldiers singing as they galloped off to join the Tzar's army. 'Where are the flowers? The girls have plucked them. Where are the girls? They've taken husbands. Where are the men? They're all in the army.' Something clicked in my subconscious; I remembered the phrase I'd thought of a couple years earlier, 'long time passing', a singable three words. Then, I added the handwringer's personal complaint, 'When will they ever learn?'Twenty minutes later, it was completed. I recorded it for Folkways in 1956 with several other short songs. A year later, I stopped singing it, thinking it another not-too-successful attempt. But Joe Hickerson, leader of the Oberlin College Folksong Club, picked it up and added two verses. He gave the song rhythm. The Kingston Trio and Peter, Paul and Mary eventually picked it up, too. (Notes 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone - The Songs of Pete Seeger') He also says - in the book of the same title, I think - that he thinks the German version superior to his own. It was written by Max Colpet (not Coplet!), a German Jewish author and songwriter (see Wikipedia). |
|
Subject: RE: Folklore: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Joe_F Date: 20 Oct 09 - 06:17 PM IMO, the song is much better as Pete Seeger wrote it. It was a mistake for Hickerson to expand it into a cycle of posies, and a bigger mistake for Seeger to accept the result. |
|
Subject: RE: Folklore: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Jim Carroll Date: 20 Oct 09 - 06:44 PM MacColl's Singers Club in London used to regularly issue 'broadsides' as handouts - this one is dated September 1962: WHERE HAVE ALL THE FLOWERS GONE Words and Music by Pete Seeger 1. Where have all the flowers gone? LONG TIME PASSING "Where have all the flowers gone? LONG TIME AGO "Where have all the flowers gone? The children picked them, every one, O, WHEN WILL YOU NEVER LEARN? WHEN WILL YOU NEVER LEARN. 2. Where have all the children gone? LONG TIME PASSING Where have all the children gone? LONG TIME AGO Where have all the children gone? They're men and women, every one, O, WHEN WILL YOU NEVER LEARN? WHEN WILL YOU NEVER LEARN 3. Where have all the young girls gone? LONG TIME PASSING Where have all the young girls gone? LONG TIME AGO Where have all the young girls gone? They've taken husbands, every one, O, WHEN WILL YOU NEVER LEARN? WHEN WILL YOU NEVER LEARN 4. Where have all the young men gone? LONG TIME PASSING Where have all the young men gone? LONG TIME AGO Where have all the young men gone? They're all in uniform, O, WHEN WILL YOU NEVER LEARN WHEN WILL YOU NEVER LEARN Jim Carroll |
|
Subject: RE: Folklore: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: GUEST,Tunesmith Date: 21 Oct 09 - 04:16 AM Pete seems to have a habit of saying that other performers improve his songs. He has certainly said that about Peter, Paul and Mary's take on "If I had a hammer". |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Joe Offer Date: 21 Oct 09 - 04:56 AM Hey, Art, we gave Joe Hickerson credit way back in January 1999 - and August 1999. You didn't think we'd forget Joe, did you? -Joe- |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Cool Beans Date: 21 Oct 09 - 02:25 PM As I recall, the original lyric appears within the first few pages of "And Quiet Flows the Don," if anyone wants to check it out. |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Q (Frank Staplin) Date: 21 Oct 09 - 02:41 PM Lyr' Add: Sag Mir, Wo Die Blumen Sind Lyrics Max Colpet (Max Kolpé, 1905-1998) 1 Sag mir, wo die Blumen sind, wo sind sie gebleiben? Sag mir, wo die Blumen sind, was ist geschehn? Sag mir, wo die Blumen sind, Mädchen pflückten sie geschwind. Wann wird man je verstehen, wann wird man je verstehen? 2 Sag mir, wo die Mädchen sind, wo sind sie gebleiben? Sag mir, wo die Mädchen sind, was ist geschehn? Sag mir, wo die Mädchen sind, Männer nahmen sie geschwind. Wann wird man je verstehn, wann wird man je verstehn? 3 Sag mir, wo doe Männer sind, wo sind gebleiben? Sag mir, wo die Männer sind, was ist geschehn? Sag mir, wo die Männer sind, zogen fort, der Krieg beginnt. Wann wird man je verstehn, wann wird man je verstehn? 4 Sag, wo die Soldaten sind, wo sind sie geblieben? Sag, wo die Soldaten sind, was ist geschehn? Sag, wo die Soldaten sind, über Gräbern weht der Wind. Wann wird man je verstehn, wann wird man je verstehn? 5 Sag mir, wo die Gräer sind, wo sind sie gebleiben? Sag mir, wo die Gräber sind, was ist geschehn? Sag mir, wo die Gräer sind, Blumen wehn im Sommerwind. Wann wird man je verstehn, wann wird man je verstehn? 6 Sag mir, wo die Blumen sind, wo sind sie gebleiben? Sag mir, wo die Blumen sind, was ist geschehn? Sag mir, wo die Blumen sind, Mädchen pflückten sie geschwind. Wann wird man je verstehn, wann wird man je verstehn? Not much German need be known to see that these are great lyrics. Max Colpet wrote many screenplays, mostly for German films, but some in French and English. |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Q (Frank Staplin) Date: 21 Oct 09 - 02:53 PM Verse 5, line 3" should be Gräber. The novel doesn't really have the words set as a lyric-although the prose is quite poetic. See Suzanne post, quoting Seeger. An excellent book; I forget who made the English translation, but it is engrossing prose. The book was picked up by many book clubs and paperback publishers, thus was widely read everywhere. |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: MGM·Lion Date: 21 Oct 09 - 03:43 PM I have an early [1934] edition of the English translation of Sholokhov's 'And Quiet Flows the Don'; the translator was Stephen Garry. |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Dave the Gnome Date: 21 Oct 09 - 04:11 PM Complete aside - Our second eldest son was going to be Mark but Mrs el G. was reading 'Quiet flows the Don' at the time and in a gas and air induced haze son number 2 became Mikhail instead - It stayed! I was realy interested to hear that the song in question was based on a Ukraine folk song though - It now goes in with 'Those were the days' and 'The Carnival is over' for me. How many more are there? DeG |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Stringsinger Date: 21 Oct 09 - 04:32 PM The melody is pure Seeger. It has the feel of one of the anthemic Russian songs, "Stenka Razin" (River of Our People). Pete's original feel for the song was slow, stirring and you could hear the balalaikas. There should be a Russian translation for the song. I never really cared for the rhumba beat that became popular. Frank |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Cool Beans Date: 21 Oct 09 - 05:06 PM The tune of "Brother, Can You Spare a Dime" is said to be based on a folk melody from that part of the world. |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Art Thieme Date: 21 Oct 09 - 05:39 PM Joe, thanks. I knew, somewhere, we probably had given Joe credit for his verses. Art |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Georgiansilver Date: 21 Oct 09 - 05:50 PM Wikipedia may often have the correct answers.... is this one correct? |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Art Thieme Date: 21 Oct 09 - 06:09 PM Mudcatters, Here is an email I got from Joe a few years back. Art Thieme To: kathy westra; sarah newcomb; Bob Molison; Ron Cohen; Mel McKeachie; mike michaels; lynn hickerson; nick reynolds; joani blank; Jim Ellis; joanna cazden; iuaaweb; art thieme; Ellie Shapiro; ellie hall; Delores Taller; deborah robins; richard burgess; bernard aptekar; Ann Schmid I thought you might be interested in this historical piece which I have submitted to the SEM (Society for Ethnomusicology) Newsletter. I did a brief presentation on this at their 50th Annual Meeting in Atlanta last November. Joyous New Year! Joe ...here is an outline of my presentation: 10/20/55 (my 20th birthday; and one month before the advent of SEM): Pete Seeger wrote the first 3 verses of "Where Have All the Flowers Gone?" on an airplane on his way to do a concert at Oberlin College (in Oberlin, Ohio). He performed it that evening in concert at First Church in Oberlin. I was there, but I did not remember the song at that time. Pete's song was a paraphrase of a Cossack song text which appeared in the novel And Quiet Flows the Don, written by the Russian novelist Mikhail Sholokhov. Early 1960: Pete's 3-verse tempo rubato rendition was issued on his Folkways LP FA 2454, Rainbow Quest. I learned the song from the LP and started singing it with guitar accompaniment at concerts and gatherings in Bloomington, Indiana . Folks liked to sing along and harmonize, but the song was so short that we repeated the 3 verses over and over. May 1960: late one night in Bloomington I composed the 4th and 5th verses for the song, and added the 1st verse at the end, thus making it a 6-verse song. Summer 1960: I taught my 6-verse version to campers and staff at Camp Woodland in Phoenicia, NY. It became one of their top-5 favorites. In August 1960 Pete Seeger visited the camp and heard the song for the first time with my added verses. At the end of the summer, staff and campers took the song back to New York City, where it was heard by Peter, Paul, and/or Mary. Fall 1961: The Kingston Trio heard PP&M sing it in Cambridge, MA, and rushed to record it at their next recording session. 1/20/62: The Kingston Trio single of the song hit the Billboard charts, where it remained until 4/21/62. It's appearance on Trio LPs ran from 3/10/62 to 6/6/64. 4/28/62: The song was included on PP&M's 1st LP, Peter Paul and Mary, which entered the Billboard charts on this date, and remained there until 11/6/65, achieving the number one position 7 weeks. 1962: Marlene Dietrich recorded a popular German version, "Sag mir, wo die Blumen sind," in Europe, which was subsequently covered by Joan Baez on an LP which appeared on the Billboard charts 10/23/65-4/9/66. 9/25/65: Johnny Rivers' rock version charted in Billboard through 1/22/66. 1968: Meanwhile, Ethel Raim and her group The Pennywhistlers recorded a Russian antecedent, "Kolada Duda." 1960s: there were two hit versions in Japan, These are discussed in an 80-minute Japanese documentary film on "Where Have All the Flowers Gone," in which I appear. 11/2/73: at the 18th SEM conference in Urbana, IL, Will Schmid delivered a paper entitled "Collected Variants of the Contemporary Folk Song, Where Have All the Flowers Gone." I thoroughly enjoyed it, even though my name was not mentioned. 1976: I received communications from German scholar, Dietrich Gerhardt, who had discovered an early printed version of the Russian song, and then that of a German precursor dated ca. 1750. A coda: the December 1962 - January 63 issue of Sing Out! (vol. 12, no. 5) printed a parody of "Where Have All the Flowers Gone," submitted by a graduate student at Indiana University. The gist was: Where have all the folksongs gone? Collector have taken them every one; where have all the collections gone? gone to archives every one; where have all the archives gone? pop singers raided them one by one; where have all the pop singers gone? gone to make records every one; where have all the records gone? the "folk" have bought them every one; where have all the pop songs gone? the folk are singing them every one; and where have all the folksongs gone etc.? A who was that brash cheeky IU grad student? It was me. Joe Hickerson |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Art Thieme Date: 21 Oct 09 - 06:19 PM I forgot I had saved it. Art |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Art Thieme Date: 22 Oct 09 - 02:52 PM refish for Joe Offer Art |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: GUEST,The Folk Entertainer Date: 22 Oct 09 - 03:12 PM I sing this song quite frequently when I perform. Kind of the Kingston Trio version which is what most casual folk music listeners like and are familiar with. This is the kind of song that the general audience doesn't care much about origins. Just that people like the song, like to sing along with it, and it brings back memories of when folk music was actually popular to the masses. Good reasons to sing it. |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Tootler Date: 23 Oct 09 - 03:01 PM To state, as Art Thieme does, that "Joe Hickerson is the one who did most of this song." to me is overstating the case. It was Pete Seeger who had the original idea and wrote the original song. Joe Hickerson in adding the extra verses changed the character of the song, IMO. I have, up in the loft, an LP in which Pete Seeger sings the original three verse version unaccompanied in live performance. In the third verse he sings
At that point he finishes the song. For me that created quite a powerful effect and gives the song a different character to the "cycle of life and death" that Joe Hickerson's extra verses give. Which you think is better is, of course, entirely up to you. |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Songbob Date: 23 Oct 09 - 03:09 PM [mode: soapbox] Every time I hear the song, though, no matter who's singing it, nor which version, I get bothered. I think it should go, "Oh, when will WE ever learn?" After all, it may be some "other" that does this -- the war-making and grave-filling -- but it's US that keeps it happening. As long as it's someone else's damned problem, then we, the singers, can cluck our disapproving tongues. But when it's OUR problem, then maybe we'll try a little harder, eh? Just maybe. [/mode: soapbox] Bob |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Joe_F Date: 23 Oct 09 - 06:30 PM Songbob: In Seeger's original version, the refrain was "Oh, when will you ever learn" until the last time, when in was indeed "Oh, when will we ever learn". That makes the point. |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Q (Frank Staplin) Date: 23 Oct 09 - 06:43 PM The German "Wand wird man je verstehen" says it well, the 'man' meaning one , thus inclusive of you, me, we, etc. |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Art Thieme Date: 23 Oct 09 - 06:56 PM Tootler, Yep, you are right. I overstated the case.-- I was forcing my point to the fore. --- Pete first--then Joe H. It's more than the sum of it's parts me thinks. Art |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Mick Woods Date: 24 Oct 09 - 04:32 AM Can somebody post the original short Pete Seeger version in it's entirety? |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Jim McLean Date: 24 Oct 09 - 02:22 PM There's a nice French version too, Ou sont vont toute les fleurs. I think all's fair in love and war when it comes to playing with traditional songs, that's the folk process, but to alter or add to an original work is, in my opinion not on. Write your own song, I would suggest. |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Q (Frank Staplin) Date: 24 Oct 09 - 03:30 PM Along with Seeger's original text, Colpet used an old song, "Sagt wo sind die Veilchen hin," by Johann Georg Jacobi, 1782. Veilchen = violets. The German version was first sung in 1962 by Marlene Dietrich (may be heard on youtube). |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Joe_F Date: 24 Oct 09 - 05:51 PM Mick Woods: From memory: "Where have all the flowers gone, Long time passing? Where have all the flowers gone, Long time ago? Where have all the flowers gone?" "Young girls have picked them, every one. Oh, when will you ever learn? Oh, when will you ever learn?" "Where have all the young girls gone?..." "They've taken husbands, every one...." "Where have all the young men gone, Long time passing? Where have all the young men gone, Long time ago? Where have all the young men gone?" "They're all in uniform. Oh, when will we ever learn? Oh, when will we ever learn?" |
|
Subject: Lyr. Add: Sagt wo sind die Veilchen hin? From: Q (Frank Staplin) Date: 24 Oct 09 - 08:41 PM Lyr. Add: Sagt wo sind die Weilchen hin? (Nach einem alten Liede) Johann Georg Jacobi (1740-1814) 1 Sagt wo sind die Veilchen hin? Die so freudig glänzten Und die Blumen Königin Ihren Weg bekränzten? Junglicg ach! Der Lenz entflieht, Diese Veilchen sind verblüht! 2 Sagt wo sind die Rosen hin? Die wir singend pflückten, Als sich Hirt und Schäferin Hut und Busen schmückten? Mädchen ach! Der Sommer flieht, Jene Rosen sind verblüht! 3 Führe denn zum Bächlein mich, Das die Veilchen tränkte; Das mit leisem Murmeln sich In die Thäler senkte. Luft und Sonne Glühten sehr, Jenes Bäachlein ist nicht mehr! English translation- Say, where have the violets gone, That once shone serenely, And made a pathway bright For the flowers so queenly? Gentle youth! the spring has fled, And the violets now are dead! Say, where have the roses gone Which we plucked as we sang, Shepherdess and shepherd bedecked, Hat and breast adorning? Dear maiden! the summer's fled, The roses, too, are dead! Lead me to the brook Where the violets were drinking; Where with gentle murmur The brook sinks into the valley. Brightly glowed both sun and air, The brook is no longer there! The similarity of this poem to "Where have all the flowers..." is unmistakable. |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Peace Date: 26 Oct 09 - 02:48 PM Thanks to all who posted new info about the song. |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Peace Date: 26 Oct 09 - 03:13 PM Q: Your research abilities and depth of 'general info' about music is remarkable. Special thanks to you. Bruce |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Gulliver Date: 29 Oct 09 - 04:17 PM I've started an article on Max Colpet on Wikipedia, here. It's mainly a translation from German sources. If anyone has any further info I'd appreciate them updating the site or PMing it to me and I'll upload it. I've also updated the German Wiki article Sag mir, wo die Blumen sind with Joe Hickerson's input (he wasn't mentioned at all!) and some other corrections. The Italian article IMHO is much better but needs a couple of citations (which I'll do shortly). Don |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Q (Frank Staplin) Date: 29 Oct 09 - 04:35 PM A better article is much needed. Max Colpet wrote many screen plays, not touched on in the brief Wiki note (a couple for American films). I also wonder if the German poem, "Sagt wo sind die Weilchen hin?" influenced Hickerson as well as Colpet? |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Gulliver Date: 29 Oct 09 - 05:18 PM Well, I only started the article a couple of hours ago... I'm not sure whether Hickerson researched the German poem, but he did research the original Russian/Ukrainian/Cossack song. Don |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Q (Frank Staplin) Date: 29 Oct 09 - 09:52 PM Which also makes me wonder if the "original" Ukrainian song was borrowed from the German. |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Gulliver Date: 29 Oct 09 - 11:19 PM Or vice versa... Another old song, of Lithuanian origin (or East Polish or Baltic - all roughly the same area), is mentioned on some German-language and Italian-language sites, called in German "Zogen einst fünf wilde Schwäne" (five wild swans once went out), dating from the 17th-century, possibly the Thirty Years War, as being possibly an antecedent of the Jacobi poem. The last of the three verses mention five young men who went off to war, none of whom returned. Zogen einst fünf wilde Schwäne, Schwäne leuchtend weiß und schön. Which brings to mind a poem, Le cinque anatre (the five ducks) by the present day Italian poet, Francesco Guccini. Don |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Q (Frank Staplin) Date: 30 Oct 09 - 01:48 PM Very similar in form. Thanks for the reference. "Zogen einst fünf wilde Schwäne" at ingeb.org; |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: Q (Frank Staplin) Date: 30 Oct 09 - 01:50 PM Link cut off- Zogen einst |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: semi-submersible Date: 30 Oct 09 - 06:27 PM Q, you said that in verse 5 above Graen should be Graben. (Sorry about the lack of accents.) The one occurrence you specified was corrected by some helpful elf; should the other two be corrected too? Farther down, should the flowers be Veilchen, Weilchen, or both? |
|
Subject: RE: Origins: 'Where Have All the Flowers Gone?' From: semi-submersible Date: 30 Oct 09 - 06:31 PM Another MudElf alert: at the top of this thread, both Digital Tradition links are duplicated. |
| Share Thread: |
